1
00:00:00,000 --> 00:00:06,000
Alessandro Oppo: Welcome to another episode of the Democracy Innovator podcast, and our guest of today is John Gastel.

2
00:00:06,000 --> 00:00:09,200
Alessandro Oppo: So thank you, John, for your time and for being here.

3
00:00:09,440 --> 00:00:11,120
John Gastil: Oh, you're welcome. It's a pleasure to be here.

4
00:00:12,405 --> 00:00:13,685
Alessandro Oppo: And the

5
00:00:13,685 --> 00:00:15,685
Alessandro Oppo: first question is if

6
00:00:15,765 --> 00:00:18,965
Alessandro Oppo: you'd like to tell us something about you, your research.

7
00:00:20,965 --> 00:00:22,485
Alessandro Oppo: I know that you have worked

8
00:00:22,965 --> 00:00:25,285
Alessandro Oppo: on many things and also you have written

9
00:00:25,580 --> 00:00:26,940
Alessandro Oppo: many different books,

10
00:00:27,500 --> 00:00:29,180
Alessandro Oppo: but they're all related to

11
00:00:30,940 --> 00:00:32,380
Alessandro Oppo: a topic like.

12
00:00:33,420 --> 00:00:34,220
John Gastil: Yeah,

13
00:00:34,780 --> 00:00:37,820
John Gastil: one way to understand my research is just to understand

14
00:00:38,300 --> 00:00:40,300
John Gastil: two things about how I grew up.

15
00:00:41,385 --> 00:00:46,505
John Gastil: So often the things we study are a reflection of what interests us or

16
00:00:47,065 --> 00:00:48,185
John Gastil: what scares us,

17
00:00:48,585 --> 00:00:50,745
John Gastil: and in my case, it's a little of both.

18
00:00:51,465 --> 00:00:53,385
John Gastil: I grew up in a very political family.

19
00:00:54,290 --> 00:00:58,050
John Gastil: Both of my parents ran for US Congress unsuccessfully,

20
00:00:59,170 --> 00:00:59,970
John Gastil: and

21
00:01:00,050 --> 00:01:02,770
John Gastil: we were constantly arguing about politics,

22
00:01:03,410 --> 00:01:05,250
John Gastil: and sometimes the arguments would get heated.

23
00:01:06,065 --> 00:01:08,305
John Gastil: The funny thing is we mostly agreed,

24
00:01:08,945 --> 00:01:12,625
John Gastil: but any small difference was worth a big argument.

25
00:01:13,265 --> 00:01:20,231
John Gastil: On the other hand, and I should add that then I did debate in high school and college, competitive debate. I really

26
00:01:20,231 --> 00:01:24,980
enjoyed it, had great success, and thought, This is something I'm really good at, arguing.

27
00:01:25,780 --> 00:01:31,540
John Gastil: On the other hand, I was raised in the tradition of Quakers, which is a relatively obscure

28
00:01:32,260 --> 00:01:33,140
John Gastil: Christian

29
00:01:33,300 --> 00:01:34,100
John Gastil: religion.

30
00:01:34,155 --> 00:01:36,555
John Gastil: It's not particularly theological.

31
00:01:37,195 --> 00:01:40,155
John Gastil: There's a tremendous emphasis on sitting in silence,

32
00:01:40,795 --> 00:01:43,755
John Gastil: being inspired to speak. There's no hierarchy.

33
00:01:44,395 --> 00:01:45,755
John Gastil: Decisions within

34
00:01:45,915 --> 00:01:48,475
John Gastil: Quaker meetings are made essentially by consensus,

35
00:01:49,240 --> 00:01:51,480
John Gastil: and famously in The United States,

36
00:01:51,720 --> 00:01:55,880
John Gastil: the Quakers were the first religious organization to formally oppose slavery,

37
00:01:56,520 --> 00:02:01,320
John Gastil: which is much more remarkable when you think about the fact that literally

38
00:02:01,480 --> 00:02:03,240
John Gastil: every single Quaker had to agree,

39
00:02:03,865 --> 00:02:10,905
John Gastil: Every single one. Any one person could block a single Quaker meeting on that issue. So here I have this consensus

40
00:02:10,905 --> 00:02:11,705
John Gastil: tradition

41
00:02:11,865 --> 00:02:14,265
John Gastil: that is so well developed historically,

42
00:02:14,265 --> 00:02:15,065
John Gastil: almost

43
00:02:15,225 --> 00:02:16,025
John Gastil: spiritually,

44
00:02:16,220 --> 00:02:24,460
John Gastil: right, that I find very attractive and interesting. I love the idea of facilitating and building consensus and listening,

45
00:02:24,460 --> 00:02:26,780
John Gastil: and on the other hand, this very aggressive

46
00:02:27,420 --> 00:02:28,940
John Gastil: political debate

47
00:02:29,820 --> 00:02:30,620
John Gastil: tradition,

48
00:02:31,245 --> 00:02:35,485
John Gastil: and in my research, you really see me working with both.

49
00:02:36,445 --> 00:02:42,440
John Gastil: On the one hand, my first book, Democracy in Small Groups, is about how groups can be democratic together. What does it

50
00:02:42,440 --> 00:02:45,165
mean to really be democratic at a very small scale?

51
00:02:46,620 --> 00:02:48,060
John Gastil: And then on the other hand,

52
00:02:48,620 --> 00:02:51,420
John Gastil: you might know that I actually ran political campaigns,

53
00:02:51,420 --> 00:02:54,380
John Gastil: like the purpose is to defeat someone,

54
00:02:54,700 --> 00:02:55,900
John Gastil: to beat them,

55
00:02:56,700 --> 00:02:57,980
John Gastil: and so

56
00:02:59,420 --> 00:03:01,820
John Gastil: reconciling those really is deliberative democracy,

57
00:03:02,315 --> 00:03:06,075
John Gastil: so whether I'm studying a jury system, is trying to use

58
00:03:07,035 --> 00:03:10,315
John Gastil: careful deliberation mixed with an adversarial process,

59
00:03:10,475 --> 00:03:11,835
John Gastil: studying elections

60
00:03:11,995 --> 00:03:16,475
John Gastil: where I want people to think through the issues, but there will be winners and losers,

61
00:03:17,340 --> 00:03:24,184
John Gastil: or mini publics, and so on. All of that research that I do in one way or another is about how to

62
00:03:24,184 --> 00:03:25,740
live together with other people

63
00:03:26,060 --> 00:03:30,460
John Gastil: in a way that brings out the best in us, makes the best decisions,

64
00:03:30,700 --> 00:03:32,300
John Gastil: and really tries to help us

65
00:03:32,815 --> 00:03:38,495
John Gastil: resolve or at least address the biggest problems we face together. It's not easy. Democracy is tough,

66
00:03:38,895 --> 00:03:40,895
John Gastil: but I think it gives me an advantage

67
00:03:40,975 --> 00:03:42,895
John Gastil: to have these very conflicting

68
00:03:43,055 --> 00:03:45,535
John Gastil: early experiences and impulses in my work.

69
00:03:46,600 --> 00:03:52,760
Alessandro Oppo: And how does it work, like, for a small group that is trying to be, let's say, democratic? How do...

70
00:03:53,560 --> 00:03:56,280
John Gastil: Yeah. I I mean, there's no one answer,

71
00:03:57,320 --> 00:04:02,245
John Gastil: and part of the point of democracy in small groups is that there really are variations

72
00:04:02,245 --> 00:04:05,685
John Gastil: on democracy that work well at a small scale,

73
00:04:05,845 --> 00:04:09,525
John Gastil: so on the one hand, there's nothing wrong with being majoritarian,

74
00:04:09,845 --> 00:04:13,365
John Gastil: right, and it's okay to have a majority vote on some things,

75
00:04:14,190 --> 00:04:19,790
John Gastil: but on other issues, particularly issues that are foundational to the identity of the group,

76
00:04:20,110 --> 00:04:22,990
John Gastil: you probably need to move closer towards consensus.

77
00:04:22,990 --> 00:04:26,510
John Gastil: So why does the jury use unanimity?

78
00:04:26,670 --> 00:04:27,790
John Gastil: Well, it doesn't always.

79
00:04:29,115 --> 00:04:37,595
John Gastil: If it's, you know, someone's charged with murder, absolutely, has to be unanimous. In fact, a Supreme Court ruling recently clarified

80
00:04:37,835 --> 00:04:43,275
John Gastil: that in a couple states that tried to deviate from that a bit, no, it has to be absolutely unanimous,

81
00:04:43,720 --> 00:04:48,200
John Gastil: but as you go down to lower stakes, let's say your car ran into my car,

82
00:04:49,000 --> 00:04:51,640
John Gastil: you know, maybe we don't require unanimity.

83
00:04:51,720 --> 00:04:53,080
John Gastil: On civil cases,

84
00:04:53,640 --> 00:04:59,643
John Gastil: where it's not, you know, a question of whether you're going to jail, but a question of often how much money someone

85
00:04:59,643 --> 00:05:00,735
has to pay someone,

86
00:05:01,535 --> 00:05:04,735
John Gastil: then typically it is like a two thirds majority or something,

87
00:05:05,615 --> 00:05:09,135
John Gastil: but I even left a little room for random

88
00:05:09,775 --> 00:05:16,552
John Gastil: selection for the decision itself, So imagine you're in a group of friends and you're trying to decide what movie to watch

89
00:05:16,552 --> 00:05:17,352
tonight,

90
00:05:17,980 --> 00:05:21,500
John Gastil: you know, if you're torn between two movies, you might do a majority vote,

91
00:05:22,060 --> 00:05:28,608
John Gastil: but then, you know, there's winners and losers and who cares? You're just gonna watch a movie, so why not flip a

92
00:05:28,608 --> 00:05:35,157
coin, right? And it turns out that random selection is used sometimes by even democratic groups because if you think about it,

93
00:05:35,157 --> 00:05:36,645
it's a perfectly fair process,

94
00:05:38,005 --> 00:05:42,885
John Gastil: it's just a different way of resolving, so there's lots of variations along those lines

95
00:05:43,420 --> 00:05:49,897
John Gastil: and I think that's a valuable lesson when you get up to a larger scale, you start to recognize, well, there's still

96
00:05:49,897 --> 00:05:50,780
variations within democracy,

97
00:05:50,780 --> 00:05:56,647
John Gastil: like voting systems and so on. Some maybe work better than others, but there's definitely more than one way to be a

98
00:05:56,647 --> 00:05:57,447
good democracy.

99
00:05:57,965 --> 00:05:58,765
Alessandro Oppo: And

100
00:05:59,245 --> 00:06:01,645
Alessandro Oppo: I was thinking before when you were saying that

101
00:06:02,685 --> 00:06:04,045
Alessandro Oppo: you were always

102
00:06:04,045 --> 00:06:06,765
Alessandro Oppo: discussing with your family about politics,

103
00:06:06,925 --> 00:06:08,845
Alessandro Oppo: and most of the times you were agreeing,

104
00:06:09,620 --> 00:06:12,100
Alessandro Oppo: But then like small differences could,

105
00:06:12,420 --> 00:06:17,620
Alessandro Oppo: you know, you could argue for maybe for hours. And I was thinking how often

106
00:06:18,580 --> 00:06:20,340
Alessandro Oppo: like the small differences

107
00:06:20,660 --> 00:06:22,100
Alessandro Oppo: inside a movement

108
00:06:22,260 --> 00:06:23,700
Alessandro Oppo: then are very, very

109
00:06:25,515 --> 00:06:26,875
Alessandro Oppo: like important.

110
00:06:26,875 --> 00:06:28,715
Alessandro Oppo: I mean, people fight a lot,

111
00:06:29,115 --> 00:06:30,315
Alessandro Oppo: and probably they

112
00:06:30,555 --> 00:06:37,755
Alessandro Oppo: maybe see like more as a enemy, the one that is like very similar to them, but with small differences

113
00:06:38,060 --> 00:06:41,740
Alessandro Oppo: instead of the other one that has a very different ideology.

114
00:06:42,700 --> 00:06:48,045
John Gastil: Well, before we began this call, you'll recall you and I, we were talking a little bit about where we've traveled, and

115
00:06:48,045 --> 00:06:49,260
we've both been to Mexico.

116
00:06:49,740 --> 00:06:51,900
John Gastil: Well, Leon Trotsky went to Mexico

117
00:06:52,535 --> 00:06:54,535
John Gastil: and was assassinated there

118
00:06:54,855 --> 00:06:56,615
John Gastil: by fellow communists

119
00:06:56,615 --> 00:06:57,495
John Gastil: because

120
00:06:57,575 --> 00:06:59,735
John Gastil: he didn't have the right version

121
00:06:59,895 --> 00:07:01,335
John Gastil: of their ideology,

122
00:07:02,615 --> 00:07:12,000
John Gastil: and you're absolutely right. I mean, these differences within a movement that shares broad goals can be so toxic

123
00:07:12,400 --> 00:07:15,120
John Gastil: that they wind up becoming personal differences,

124
00:07:15,200 --> 00:07:17,520
John Gastil: differences in personality and style,

125
00:07:18,160 --> 00:07:22,240
John Gastil: and sometimes that covers up real substantive debates that need to happen.

126
00:07:22,995 --> 00:07:25,155
John Gastil: The challenge, I think, often in a movement

127
00:07:25,395 --> 00:07:28,355
John Gastil: is how do we maintain our solidarity

128
00:07:28,355 --> 00:07:30,035
John Gastil: and our shared focus

129
00:07:30,595 --> 00:07:32,195
John Gastil: while still having

130
00:07:32,595 --> 00:07:34,675
John Gastil: really good internal deliberation,

131
00:07:35,260 --> 00:07:36,460
John Gastil: and in fact,

132
00:07:37,180 --> 00:07:39,900
John Gastil: again, a colleague of mine in Italy, Andrea Felicetti,

133
00:07:39,980 --> 00:07:43,660
John Gastil: a part of his research is on social movements and deliberation,

134
00:07:44,140 --> 00:07:48,300
John Gastil: and looking at what is the potential for a movement to either foster

135
00:07:48,300 --> 00:07:50,540
John Gastil: sort of a national deliberation

136
00:07:51,025 --> 00:07:57,185
John Gastil: while still having movement aims, right, where there's an outcome we want, but we can still promote deliberation,

137
00:07:57,905 --> 00:08:01,665
John Gastil: but crucially, how do we maintain a deliberative culture within our movement?

138
00:08:01,825 --> 00:08:03,105
John Gastil: It's not always easy,

139
00:08:03,980 --> 00:08:06,780
John Gastil: but if you are a democratic social movement,

140
00:08:07,420 --> 00:08:12,700
John Gastil: this has to be part of your identity. Your internal democratic process has to be authentic

141
00:08:12,860 --> 00:08:14,060
John Gastil: and really

142
00:08:14,060 --> 00:08:15,420
John Gastil: deliberative and robust,

143
00:08:16,125 --> 00:08:24,205
John Gastil: or it's too easy to fall into the kinds of hierarchies and personality fights that can destroy a movement or corrupt it.

144
00:08:25,405 --> 00:08:27,725
Alessandro Oppo: Yeah. That happens a lot of times.

145
00:08:27,965 --> 00:08:28,765
Alessandro Oppo: They can

146
00:08:29,645 --> 00:08:31,085
Alessandro Oppo: Yeah. And

147
00:08:32,650 --> 00:08:34,730
Alessandro Oppo: it was very interesting what

148
00:08:35,530 --> 00:08:37,210
Alessandro Oppo: you said about the

149
00:08:37,930 --> 00:08:39,290
Alessandro Oppo: Quaker community,

150
00:08:39,530 --> 00:08:40,330
Alessandro Oppo: like...

151
00:08:41,370 --> 00:08:43,050
Alessandro Oppo: And I was thinking how

152
00:08:43,735 --> 00:08:48,295
Alessandro Oppo: does it work like the governance inside the... Because you mentioned consensus,

153
00:08:48,535 --> 00:08:50,295
Alessandro Oppo: that is a very interesting things.

154
00:08:50,855 --> 00:08:53,015
Alessandro Oppo: And yeah, if there are other

155
00:08:53,415 --> 00:08:55,175
Alessandro Oppo: things that could be interesting to know.

156
00:08:55,930 --> 00:09:00,090
John Gastil: At like a national level you're saying, or just any large scale?

157
00:09:00,570 --> 00:09:01,610
Alessandro Oppo: Yeah. At...

158
00:09:01,930 --> 00:09:04,810
Alessandro Oppo: I will say what is the kind of organization

159
00:09:05,290 --> 00:09:08,730
Alessandro Oppo: in relation to, let's say, governance that is used?

160
00:09:09,130 --> 00:09:11,965
Alessandro Oppo: I mean, I can imagine some assembly with consensus,

161
00:09:11,965 --> 00:09:12,765
Alessandro Oppo: but then

162
00:09:13,245 --> 00:09:14,045
Alessandro Oppo: how Sure, does

163
00:09:15,485 --> 00:09:18,605
John Gastil: so let's

164
00:09:18,605 --> 00:09:25,140
John Gastil: think broadly about the concept of a mini public for a second. So a mini public, broadly speaking,

165
00:09:25,540 --> 00:09:31,380
John Gastil: is a random sample of some political unit, like a nation or a state or a city,

166
00:09:31,780 --> 00:09:35,140
John Gastil: that's brought together either online or in person

167
00:09:35,780 --> 00:09:36,820
John Gastil: to discuss

168
00:09:37,305 --> 00:09:40,985
John Gastil: usually an issue or maybe a set of issues

169
00:09:41,945 --> 00:09:46,265
John Gastil: and do something about them. Usually, it's make a recommendation.

170
00:09:46,425 --> 00:09:53,857
John Gastil: Sometimes it's more than that. Some mini publics actually analyze an issue and then provide information to voters who are gonna vote

171
00:09:53,857 --> 00:09:54,870
on that issue.

172
00:09:55,430 --> 00:10:02,335
John Gastil: Some mini publics get to place a question on the ballot for voters to vote up or down, or they hand that

173
00:10:02,335 --> 00:10:03,590
issue to the legislature,

174
00:10:03,935 --> 00:10:11,289
John Gastil: which then hopefully follows through on a promise to then put it on the ballot. They do various things, right, from recommendations

175
00:10:11,289 --> 00:10:13,295
to providing information and so on.

176
00:10:14,495 --> 00:10:15,935
John Gastil: These mini publics

177
00:10:16,255 --> 00:10:21,270
John Gastil: are sometimes confused with the entire project of deliberative democracy.

178
00:10:21,430 --> 00:10:25,110
John Gastil: All they really are is one institutional innovation

179
00:10:25,670 --> 00:10:26,470
John Gastil: that

180
00:10:26,550 --> 00:10:29,190
John Gastil: very effectively illustrates

181
00:10:29,705 --> 00:10:30,505
John Gastil: the

182
00:10:31,145 --> 00:10:35,865
John Gastil: need for a deliberative moment within an adversarial process.

183
00:10:35,945 --> 00:10:39,945
John Gastil: What I mean by that is the mini publics tend to be highly deliberative.

184
00:10:40,905 --> 00:10:42,825
John Gastil: Really, if you design it well,

185
00:10:43,145 --> 00:10:45,065
John Gastil: it's hard to find a good

186
00:10:45,330 --> 00:10:48,210
John Gastil: case where it totally failed to deliberate.

187
00:10:49,490 --> 00:10:53,410
John Gastil: Usually when the deliberation becomes messy and problematic,

188
00:10:53,490 --> 00:10:59,172
John Gastil: usually you gave it too many things to do in a short period of time, or you didn't give it the information

189
00:10:59,172 --> 00:11:03,305
resources it needed or so on, but well designed mini publics work great as deliberate bodies.

190
00:11:03,625 --> 00:11:07,305
John Gastil: The question is, do they have any relevance beyond themselves,

191
00:11:07,625 --> 00:11:11,305
John Gastil: and if they're well integrated into like an election, for instance,

192
00:11:11,625 --> 00:11:13,625
John Gastil: yeah, they're absolutely consequential.

193
00:11:13,930 --> 00:11:20,730
John Gastil: In Ireland, they liberalized abortion laws because a mini public deliberated on a difficult issue in a Catholic country

194
00:11:20,970 --> 00:11:26,570
John Gastil: and came up with a proposal that was broadly acceptable to the public, and they ratified it through a vote.

195
00:11:27,355 --> 00:11:29,435
John Gastil: In Oregon or in Geneva,

196
00:11:29,995 --> 00:11:32,715
John Gastil: they used the Citizens Initiative review process

197
00:11:33,275 --> 00:11:34,315
John Gastil: to analyze

198
00:11:34,875 --> 00:11:41,669
John Gastil: an issue on the ballot and help voters like you and me read that statement and say, oh, I understand. Okay, I

199
00:11:41,669 --> 00:11:44,140
understand what I'm voting on now. I now

200
00:11:44,780 --> 00:11:50,834
John Gastil: want to vote yes or I want to vote no. The point is we're now more confident, we're well informed, so the

201
00:11:50,834 --> 00:11:51,660
deliberation is improving

202
00:11:52,145 --> 00:11:54,865
John Gastil: the election and getting you a better outcome.

203
00:11:56,385 --> 00:11:58,785
John Gastil: That doesn't make society deliberative,

204
00:11:58,785 --> 00:12:01,265
John Gastil: it doesn't mean we reach consensus,

205
00:12:01,585 --> 00:12:03,985
John Gastil: but it does mean there's more deliberation

206
00:12:03,985 --> 00:12:04,865
John Gastil: infused

207
00:12:04,865 --> 00:12:05,985
John Gastil: into our politics,

208
00:12:06,960 --> 00:12:08,960
John Gastil: and I think in the long run,

209
00:12:09,440 --> 00:12:13,040
John Gastil: one of the things that we'll do is build up the legitimacy

210
00:12:13,040 --> 00:12:16,400
John Gastil: of democracy itself and end the deliberative

211
00:12:18,240 --> 00:12:24,185
John Gastil: processes in democracy. Just one more example, as you know, I studied the jury process for many years.

212
00:12:24,585 --> 00:12:30,585
John Gastil: One of the things that serving on a jury does is it makes you more confident in the legal process.

213
00:12:30,745 --> 00:12:35,545
John Gastil: Not always, but in general it does because people tend to have a positive experience.

214
00:12:37,350 --> 00:12:42,390
John Gastil: That building up of confidence in an institution can help that institution work well.

215
00:12:43,030 --> 00:12:45,670
John Gastil: You don't want it to be unwarranted trust,

216
00:12:45,830 --> 00:12:48,870
John Gastil: right? You don't want to trust in an institution that is terrible,

217
00:12:49,430 --> 00:12:52,975
John Gastil: but when you serve as a jury, you see it unmediated.

218
00:12:52,975 --> 00:12:56,495
John Gastil: Those are your eyes looking at the judge, looking at the process,

219
00:12:57,855 --> 00:12:58,655
John Gastil: and

220
00:12:59,375 --> 00:13:04,255
John Gastil: in a way, a mini public helps do that for politics to some degree.

221
00:13:05,970 --> 00:13:14,290
John Gastil: It's not the same, but it can help people feel like, okay, our politics is not just misinformation,

222
00:13:14,690 --> 00:13:15,490
John Gastil: personality,

223
00:13:16,210 --> 00:13:17,090
John Gastil: deception.

224
00:13:17,730 --> 00:13:25,865
John Gastil: It does also include these moments of deliberation, so I think if if well designed and integrated into your political system,

225
00:13:26,265 --> 00:13:29,545
John Gastil: those deliberative moments, I think, can have powerful lessons

226
00:13:29,625 --> 00:13:32,985
John Gastil: for all of us in how we think about ourselves and our role in democracy.

227
00:13:33,640 --> 00:13:34,440
Alessandro Oppo: And

228
00:13:34,520 --> 00:13:37,320
Alessandro Oppo: now, yeah, I wanted to ask you like the... Because

229
00:13:39,400 --> 00:13:42,120
Alessandro Oppo: before you said like in the Quaker community,

230
00:13:42,360 --> 00:13:43,160
Alessandro Oppo: in the

231
00:13:44,440 --> 00:13:45,960
Alessandro Oppo: consensus is used

232
00:13:46,125 --> 00:13:47,565
Alessandro Oppo: and not majority.

233
00:13:48,445 --> 00:13:51,885
Alessandro Oppo: So I wonder, like, which other kind of mechanism

234
00:13:52,445 --> 00:13:55,645
Alessandro Oppo: they used or they are using now.

235
00:13:56,285 --> 00:14:03,779
John Gastil: So I... It... It's it's worth noting. I I was raised Quaker, I became officially a Quaker sometime when I was in

236
00:14:03,779 --> 00:14:04,579
college,

237
00:14:04,440 --> 00:14:09,400
John Gastil: it's a whole story there, and now I'm no longer officially Quaker. I'm culturally Quaker.

238
00:14:10,360 --> 00:14:12,040
John Gastil: On my first date with my partner,

239
00:14:13,185 --> 00:14:19,383
John Gastil: I realized after the fact I must have mentioned Quakerism like eight times. I felt like an idiot. We're still together, so

240
00:14:19,383 --> 00:14:25,582
I guess no harm done, but it's weird how it becomes a part of you even if you're no longer part of

241
00:14:25,582 --> 00:14:26,382
the religion,

242
00:14:26,610 --> 00:14:32,690
John Gastil: and Quakers are formally called the Religious Society of Friends, with a capital F,

243
00:14:33,970 --> 00:14:34,770
John Gastil: and

244
00:14:34,930 --> 00:14:36,530
John Gastil: it is a religious society,

245
00:14:36,770 --> 00:14:40,130
John Gastil: so there have actually been books written about Quaker process,

246
00:14:40,210 --> 00:14:42,885
John Gastil: and usually they're very careful to say this,

247
00:14:44,485 --> 00:14:48,885
John Gastil: Quakers are sometimes offended when you tell them that they run by consensus

248
00:14:49,205 --> 00:14:57,005
John Gastil: because they think they make all their decisions through a religious process, not through what you and I would recognize as good

249
00:14:57,005 --> 00:14:57,805
facilitation,

250
00:14:57,360 --> 00:14:58,960
John Gastil: effective listening,

251
00:14:59,280 --> 00:15:00,240
John Gastil: bargaining,

252
00:15:00,240 --> 00:15:01,040
John Gastil: no.

253
00:15:01,200 --> 00:15:08,160
John Gastil: Everyone is supposed to be inspired by the Holy Spirit, some supernatural force that inspires you to speak and to listen,

254
00:15:09,715 --> 00:15:14,995
John Gastil: and we're finding the truth. The truth was already there. We're all just sort of finding it, and

255
00:15:15,635 --> 00:15:19,875
John Gastil: no one has more authority over anyone else. It's very Habermasian

256
00:15:19,955 --> 00:15:24,435
John Gastil: in the sense that everyone's validity claims can be challenged, everyone is supposed to be equal,

257
00:15:25,610 --> 00:15:26,410
John Gastil: but

258
00:15:26,490 --> 00:15:30,010
John Gastil: their answer to that question is that it's a spiritual practice,

259
00:15:30,650 --> 00:15:34,890
John Gastil: but one of the best books written on Quaker process has a quote from a Quaker,

260
00:15:35,450 --> 00:15:37,850
John Gastil: which is, How do you reach consensus on an issue

261
00:15:38,615 --> 00:15:46,615
John Gastil: or unanimity or whatever when someone disagrees and they're adamant about their disagreement? The example was gay marriage.

262
00:15:46,775 --> 00:15:50,615
John Gastil: Most Quaker meetings are happy to welcome in

263
00:15:50,695 --> 00:15:55,700
John Gastil: gay and lesbian couples to become married. That was true even before it became the law in The United States,

264
00:15:56,020 --> 00:15:58,980
John Gastil: but there were exceptions. There are meetings that did not

265
00:15:59,540 --> 00:16:06,020
John Gastil: support that, and the answer was we will reach consensus once we have a few good Quaker funerals,

266
00:16:07,585 --> 00:16:09,665
John Gastil: meaning a few people need to die.

267
00:16:10,385 --> 00:16:16,305
John Gastil: Now, not that we're gonna kill them, it is a non violent religion, they don't even go to war under any circumstance,

268
00:16:16,305 --> 00:16:17,825
John Gastil: but they can certainly

269
00:16:18,720 --> 00:16:23,760
John Gastil: wait someone out and then vote again after they have passed from natural causes.

270
00:16:24,480 --> 00:16:28,160
John Gastil: So that is a recognition of the reality of vote counting,

271
00:16:28,880 --> 00:16:32,515
John Gastil: they're not saying well the Holy Spirit is not

272
00:16:32,515 --> 00:16:36,515
John Gastil: reaching these members well, no, they're saying they just need to go.

273
00:16:37,795 --> 00:16:43,235
John Gastil: So, know, it's funny, but I think there is something to that and when you watch a mini public,

274
00:16:43,810 --> 00:16:47,570
John Gastil: it's obviously gonna be secular. Well, not obviously, but genuinely,

275
00:16:48,370 --> 00:16:50,130
John Gastil: in the humanist tradition.

276
00:16:50,530 --> 00:16:52,050
John Gastil: There is not usually

277
00:16:52,770 --> 00:16:56,770
John Gastil: a moment of prayer in a mini public because it's a diverse group and there's no,

278
00:16:57,515 --> 00:16:59,995
John Gastil: and yet, if you watch closely,

279
00:17:00,635 --> 00:17:05,835
John Gastil: you will see that there are elements of it that are not about rational argument.

280
00:17:06,395 --> 00:17:08,475
John Gastil: They're about sharing identity,

281
00:17:08,475 --> 00:17:09,595
John Gastil: having meals together,

282
00:17:10,090 --> 00:17:12,410
John Gastil: having a sense of common purpose,

283
00:17:13,130 --> 00:17:14,730
John Gastil: inside jokes develop,

284
00:17:14,810 --> 00:17:17,370
John Gastil: things that we all laugh at that no one would understand.

285
00:17:18,410 --> 00:17:23,130
John Gastil: There's a technical term in small group research called symbolic

286
00:17:23,130 --> 00:17:23,930
John Gastil: convergence,

287
00:17:24,435 --> 00:17:30,843
John Gastil: which means that you know we all exist in these complex symbol systems, right? You have your favorite movie and when you're

288
00:17:30,843 --> 00:17:35,795
with friends who've seen that movie, you can make a reference to it and they all laugh.

289
00:17:36,195 --> 00:17:40,275
John Gastil: I was playing video games last night with an old friend from high school

290
00:17:40,650 --> 00:17:42,570
John Gastil: and he made a movie reference

291
00:17:42,650 --> 00:17:43,930
John Gastil: and I laughed

292
00:17:44,250 --> 00:17:50,155
John Gastil: but then I said, I'm not sure I'm laughing at the right movie and he said, were you thinking of this movie?

293
00:17:50,155 --> 00:17:52,570
And I said, no and he said, oh you

294
00:17:52,570 --> 00:17:57,805
John Gastil: need to go watch this Smokey and the Bandit again, some movie from the 1970s with Burt Reynolds.

295
00:17:58,285 --> 00:18:05,255
John Gastil: So we laughed and had a good time because of the complexity of our symbol systems, and we're trying to merge them

296
00:18:05,255 --> 00:18:06,205
all the time.

297
00:18:08,020 --> 00:18:10,900
John Gastil: Well, these mini publics do the same thing, right? They

298
00:18:11,540 --> 00:18:18,330
John Gastil: have ways of making people feel like they belong and there's something special, and sometimes they'll even talk as though something

299
00:18:18,330 --> 00:18:19,300
magical is happening,

300
00:18:19,825 --> 00:18:22,865
John Gastil: right? Something almost supernatural.

301
00:18:23,345 --> 00:18:30,660
John Gastil: I can't believe that I could sit down with 200 people from across my country and we could have this experience, right?

302
00:18:30,660 --> 00:18:33,985
In Australia, I'm remembering they had a parliament with 150

303
00:18:33,985 --> 00:18:39,800
John Gastil: people randomly selected except that they included, I think, five Aboriginal Australians

304
00:18:40,360 --> 00:18:45,800
John Gastil: who were quasi random, but they just wanted to make sure they represented people with a very distinct

305
00:18:45,960 --> 00:18:47,880
John Gastil: historical and cultural experience,

306
00:18:48,280 --> 00:18:51,160
John Gastil: and at one of the plenary sessions, one of them spoke

307
00:18:51,475 --> 00:18:52,915
John Gastil: about feeling

308
00:18:52,995 --> 00:18:54,115
John Gastil: Australian,

309
00:18:54,595 --> 00:18:57,955
John Gastil: like that national identity, and that may not sound magical to you,

310
00:18:58,515 --> 00:19:05,460
John Gastil: but everybody started crying. I'm almost crying telling you about it. I had the privilege of being there studying it, and

311
00:19:05,540 --> 00:19:13,269
John Gastil: there's something else going on there, right? It's not that I say, well, I look forward to challenging your validity claims later.

312
00:19:13,269 --> 00:19:14,069
No,

313
00:19:13,860 --> 00:19:19,155
John Gastil: I'm excited to be sharing a space with someone who is part of my national history,

314
00:19:19,395 --> 00:19:24,515
John Gastil: who I'm otherwise never gonna meet, unconnected with, yet today you feel like a friend,

315
00:19:24,755 --> 00:19:25,795
John Gastil: like a neighbor,

316
00:19:26,595 --> 00:19:28,595
John Gastil: and so there is a kind of magic

317
00:19:28,755 --> 00:19:29,955
John Gastil: in deliberation

318
00:19:29,955 --> 00:19:31,795
John Gastil: that the Quakers understand

319
00:19:31,800 --> 00:19:34,200
John Gastil: they've made it into a whole religious brand,

320
00:19:35,320 --> 00:19:41,122
John Gastil: but very few of us will ever experience that, but if we're randomly selected, we might get a taste of it in

321
00:19:41,122 --> 00:19:42,440
one of these deliberative processes.

322
00:19:44,135 --> 00:19:47,175
Alessandro Oppo: This is very interesting. And I was thinking when you were...

323
00:19:48,615 --> 00:19:49,975
Alessandro Oppo: When you say symbolic

324
00:19:49,975 --> 00:19:50,855
Alessandro Oppo: convergence

325
00:19:51,495 --> 00:19:53,175
Alessandro Oppo: at nations,

326
00:19:53,335 --> 00:19:55,095
Alessandro Oppo: at also religions

327
00:19:55,335 --> 00:19:56,135
Alessandro Oppo: that,

328
00:19:57,990 --> 00:19:58,790
Alessandro Oppo: I mean,

329
00:19:59,190 --> 00:20:02,470
Alessandro Oppo: being part of a country, feeling, I don't know, Italian,

330
00:20:02,950 --> 00:20:04,870
Alessandro Oppo: Canadian, or whatever,

331
00:20:05,590 --> 00:20:07,110
Alessandro Oppo: is like a convergence.

332
00:20:07,670 --> 00:20:15,399
Alessandro Oppo: But then what happened like in comparison to like, let's say, a mini public is that when we are too many, it's

333
00:20:15,399 --> 00:20:17,155
very hard to organize and

334
00:20:17,875 --> 00:20:20,355
Alessandro Oppo: the governance things is very hard.

335
00:20:20,995 --> 00:20:23,235
Alessandro Oppo: And usually we have hierarchies.

336
00:20:26,390 --> 00:20:27,270
Alessandro Oppo: But then

337
00:20:28,310 --> 00:20:34,230
Alessandro Oppo: that has a lot of praise, we can say, because then make the organization easier, but also a lot of

338
00:20:34,790 --> 00:20:35,590
Alessandro Oppo: cons.

339
00:20:36,275 --> 00:20:37,075
Alessandro Oppo: And,

340
00:20:37,715 --> 00:20:39,715
Alessandro Oppo: yeah, what are your thoughts about this?

341
00:20:41,475 --> 00:20:47,555
John Gastil: Let me make sure I understand the question. What I'm hearing you say is a lot of governments

342
00:20:47,795 --> 00:20:50,250
John Gastil: don't want that kind of deliberation,

343
00:20:50,250 --> 00:20:52,330
John Gastil: and they're kind of structurally built

344
00:20:52,650 --> 00:20:54,490
John Gastil: to maintain hierarchy.

345
00:20:54,970 --> 00:20:57,850
John Gastil: Is that where you're going, or is there something more you're

346
00:20:57,850 --> 00:20:59,530
John Gastil: you're asking specifically?

347
00:21:00,410 --> 00:21:02,650
Alessandro Oppo: No. I was thinking also about

348
00:21:03,465 --> 00:21:05,225
Alessandro Oppo: these things that

349
00:21:05,225 --> 00:21:11,305
Alessandro Oppo: I've read in a book that was from Yuval Noah Harari, it's something that I always have in my mind that

350
00:21:11,865 --> 00:21:14,105
Alessandro Oppo: he was saying that most of animals

351
00:21:14,825 --> 00:21:15,625
Alessandro Oppo: after

352
00:21:16,105 --> 00:21:18,490
Alessandro Oppo: they are more than 150

353
00:21:18,490 --> 00:21:19,370
Alessandro Oppo: members,

354
00:21:19,450 --> 00:21:20,810
Alessandro Oppo: usually they split,

355
00:21:21,130 --> 00:21:22,250
Alessandro Oppo: while other

356
00:21:22,410 --> 00:21:24,810
Alessandro Oppo: as humans, were able to

357
00:21:25,130 --> 00:21:27,850
Alessandro Oppo: create things that do not really exist,

358
00:21:28,250 --> 00:21:33,335
Alessandro Oppo: let's say in the real world, but they are in our mind. So like Yeah. I mean, Italy

359
00:21:33,895 --> 00:21:34,695
Alessandro Oppo: or

360
00:21:34,775 --> 00:21:38,215
Alessandro Oppo: another country is not really written on the earth,

361
00:21:38,695 --> 00:21:39,975
Alessandro Oppo: but it's something that

362
00:21:40,295 --> 00:21:43,655
Alessandro Oppo: we agree that this is Italy, and that is France, I don't know,

363
00:21:45,030 --> 00:21:48,230
Alessandro Oppo: or that we are all Christian or Muslims,

364
00:21:48,550 --> 00:21:51,830
Alessandro Oppo: and so this keep us, let's say united,

365
00:21:52,550 --> 00:21:53,670
Alessandro Oppo: but then

366
00:21:55,030 --> 00:21:58,150
Alessandro Oppo: if we are a lot of people, then it's

367
00:21:58,150 --> 00:21:59,430
Alessandro Oppo: hard, let's say to keep,

368
00:22:00,395 --> 00:22:02,155
Alessandro Oppo: let's say to use consensus.

369
00:22:02,795 --> 00:22:04,075
Alessandro Oppo: And so we

370
00:22:05,195 --> 00:22:07,115
Alessandro Oppo: find different ways of governance.

371
00:22:09,435 --> 00:22:15,955
John Gastil: A book I wrote called The Group in Society is it's partly meant as a kind of a textbook for teaching a

372
00:22:15,955 --> 00:22:20,400
course on small groups, but it was also an attempt to write a theoretical book

373
00:22:20,640 --> 00:22:22,560
John Gastil: about how groups function,

374
00:22:23,520 --> 00:22:29,415
John Gastil: and one of the questions that comes up always with small group research is what is a small group, How

375
00:22:29,415 --> 00:22:31,255
John Gastil: big can a small group become?

376
00:22:32,695 --> 00:22:34,295
John Gastil: There's a confusing

377
00:22:34,375 --> 00:22:35,655
John Gastil: correct answer,

378
00:22:36,135 --> 00:22:39,335
John Gastil: which is it's not obvious what the upper limit is.

379
00:22:40,870 --> 00:22:42,230
John Gastil: Three is the minimum.

380
00:22:42,390 --> 00:22:45,350
John Gastil: If you have two people, you have a dyad, you have two people,

381
00:22:46,470 --> 00:22:47,270
John Gastil: majority

382
00:22:47,910 --> 00:22:52,630
John Gastil: rule is the same as unanimity, right? It's either two to nothing or one to one, right?

383
00:22:53,190 --> 00:22:55,430
John Gastil: Three people, you start to have a coalition and so

384
00:22:56,215 --> 00:23:00,375
John Gastil: and you know, people talk about the number 12 or the number 24.

385
00:23:00,775 --> 00:23:02,935
John Gastil: It's not surprising that juries,

386
00:23:03,095 --> 00:23:06,295
John Gastil: you know, the maximum size for a typical jury is 12.

387
00:23:07,095 --> 00:23:11,735
John Gastil: A classroom is still considered small when there's only 22,

388
00:23:10,960 --> 00:23:16,320
John Gastil: 24 people, right? You start to get into a large classroom when you're over 30 people and so on,

389
00:23:17,280 --> 00:23:18,080
John Gastil: but

390
00:23:19,920 --> 00:23:24,720
John Gastil: not to overuse the example of Quakers, but when they gather for say a regional

391
00:23:24,880 --> 00:23:28,645
John Gastil: meeting, there could be hundreds of people, and they'll still run by consensus.

392
00:23:28,965 --> 00:23:32,645
John Gastil: Now, why can they do that? Because of how much they have in common,

393
00:23:32,885 --> 00:23:39,525
John Gastil: right? Not just that they have a common background and belong to the same religious group, but they have a shared understanding

394
00:23:39,525 --> 00:23:40,565
John Gastil: of procedure,

395
00:23:40,565 --> 00:23:42,870
John Gastil: a complex and delicate procedure.

396
00:23:43,190 --> 00:23:44,710
John Gastil: For instance, with Quakers,

397
00:23:44,950 --> 00:23:49,190
John Gastil: you can object to a decision but choose to stand aside,

398
00:23:49,590 --> 00:23:50,390
John Gastil: meaning

399
00:23:50,950 --> 00:23:56,683
John Gastil: essentially it's like if you all say that one sports team is gonna win, I can say, you know what, go ahead

400
00:23:56,683 --> 00:23:57,725
and place that bet,

401
00:23:57,965 --> 00:24:02,685
John Gastil: but I'm gonna stand aside so that when that team loses, I will say, I told you so.

402
00:24:02,845 --> 00:24:07,325
John Gastil: I will tell, I told you you were wrong, I let you do the foolish thing,

403
00:24:07,565 --> 00:24:09,885
John Gastil: but I'm on the record saying you're idiots,

404
00:24:10,765 --> 00:24:16,633
John Gastil: but I can block it, I can absolutely block it and say, No, we're not gonna do this. So that delicate balance

405
00:24:16,633 --> 00:24:18,500
is one of the things they manage,

406
00:24:18,740 --> 00:24:20,740
John Gastil: but there are also cooperatives.

407
00:24:20,740 --> 00:24:27,539
John Gastil: You've surely heard of Burning Man in the desert. There are things that are less expensive like the rainbow gathering and these

408
00:24:27,539 --> 00:24:34,338
other sort of hippie groups that can get together and run by consensus with again hundreds of people because of shared norms,

409
00:24:34,338 --> 00:24:35,265
understandings, and procedures.

410
00:24:35,425 --> 00:24:38,705
John Gastil: I was part of a protest movement in Wisconsin

411
00:24:38,705 --> 00:24:41,290
John Gastil: during one of the many U. S. Wars,

412
00:24:41,610 --> 00:24:43,290
John Gastil: this was back in the 90s,

413
00:24:43,450 --> 00:24:46,890
John Gastil: and we reached consensus on how to protest,

414
00:24:47,210 --> 00:24:55,095
John Gastil: and it was a we talked before about how you know how small disagreements can become explosive within a social movement, but

415
00:24:55,095 --> 00:24:57,245
we had very different tactical strategies,

416
00:24:57,405 --> 00:24:59,485
John Gastil: some of which involved civil disobedience,

417
00:24:59,485 --> 00:25:03,805
John Gastil: and we wound up reaching a consensus through a very aggressively

418
00:25:03,805 --> 00:25:04,685
John Gastil: facilitated

419
00:25:04,685 --> 00:25:05,485
John Gastil: process,

420
00:25:05,645 --> 00:25:11,430
John Gastil: constantly moving into small discussions and coming back together, so it can be done at larger and larger scales.

421
00:25:12,070 --> 00:25:13,110
John Gastil: That said,

422
00:25:14,070 --> 00:25:15,910
John Gastil: even for small groups,

423
00:25:16,230 --> 00:25:17,190
John Gastil: I encourage

424
00:25:17,190 --> 00:25:20,070
John Gastil: not relying on consensus or unanimity

425
00:25:21,145 --> 00:25:22,025
John Gastil: because

426
00:25:22,185 --> 00:25:24,585
John Gastil: really, I think you want the spirit

427
00:25:24,825 --> 00:25:26,345
John Gastil: of consensus,

428
00:25:26,745 --> 00:25:29,225
John Gastil: but you need to have voting procedures

429
00:25:29,305 --> 00:25:30,905
John Gastil: that don't require it.

430
00:25:31,465 --> 00:25:38,062
John Gastil: Even at the small group level, my very first book was studying a small grocery co op, they were a grocery store

431
00:25:38,062 --> 00:25:42,860
that ran through a democratic process, all their staff, well they basically needed to fire someone.

432
00:25:43,500 --> 00:25:46,220
John Gastil: Guess what, she blocked consensus every time,

433
00:25:46,460 --> 00:25:50,300
John Gastil: she didn't want to be fired, and they really didn't have a solution to that problem,

434
00:25:51,095 --> 00:25:58,239
John Gastil: So, you know, it's funny, but it's also kind of obvious that you need something that lets you, at some point, take

435
00:25:58,239 --> 00:26:02,135
a vote, and you'll see this in many publics sometimes in reverse,

436
00:26:02,375 --> 00:26:07,440
John Gastil: where in British Columbia, they had a large gathering of people deciding on a voting procedure,

437
00:26:08,000 --> 00:26:14,547
John Gastil: they had a clever step where they took an informal vote. It was clear what the preferred procedure was. It was something

438
00:26:14,547 --> 00:26:15,440
called single transferable

439
00:26:15,440 --> 00:26:19,685
John Gastil: vote, and they were going to recommend a version of that for British Columbia Canada.

440
00:26:20,245 --> 00:26:26,485
John Gastil: After the informal vote, they said, now let's take the final official vote which goes into the record

441
00:26:26,805 --> 00:26:30,165
John Gastil: and wouldn't you know it, the majority got even larger,

442
00:26:30,565 --> 00:26:31,365
John Gastil: right?

443
00:26:31,780 --> 00:26:37,620
John Gastil: Because what people were saying was, well, I really preferred proportional representation or something else,

444
00:26:38,100 --> 00:26:43,300
John Gastil: but I want to show the public that we came together on a proposal

445
00:26:43,765 --> 00:26:49,799
John Gastil: and so, you know, there's these clever things you can do in design that make sure everyone's voice gets heard and they

446
00:26:49,799 --> 00:26:51,445
have a place for their dissent,

447
00:26:51,845 --> 00:26:53,845
John Gastil: but you still have a strong majority,

448
00:26:53,925 --> 00:26:56,165
John Gastil: so it is partly a question of design,

449
00:26:57,060 --> 00:27:00,020
John Gastil: but also a question of symbolic significance.

450
00:27:00,420 --> 00:27:04,100
John Gastil: Just the last point on this is we haven't yet talked about the EU.

451
00:27:04,420 --> 00:27:07,540
John Gastil: The EU is funding deliberative processes all the time,

452
00:27:07,860 --> 00:27:10,420
John Gastil: and the EU is very much in the business

453
00:27:10,580 --> 00:27:12,100
John Gastil: of symbolic convergence.

454
00:27:12,555 --> 00:27:17,115
John Gastil: They want EU members to feel like they belong to something called the EU

455
00:27:17,275 --> 00:27:22,555
John Gastil: and when they hold a deliberation that involves the EU, obviously they have to have so many languages,

456
00:27:22,875 --> 00:27:27,035
John Gastil: but they have to find a way for people to feel like they were part of one

457
00:27:27,870 --> 00:27:28,670
John Gastil: thing

458
00:27:28,670 --> 00:27:31,150
John Gastil: while still retaining their identity

459
00:27:31,390 --> 00:27:38,130
John Gastil: and that's a delicate balance, but it can be done and I think we've seen some positive efforts, some good examples of

460
00:27:38,130 --> 00:27:44,870
deliberation in the EU, so I think this can be achieved, you can bring large groups together, but it takes a lot

461
00:27:44,870 --> 00:27:47,015
of work and a lot of practice.

462
00:27:47,895 --> 00:27:50,855
Alessandro Oppo: And I was thinking, we can say that maybe

463
00:27:51,095 --> 00:27:51,895
Alessandro Oppo: like

464
00:27:52,375 --> 00:27:54,615
Alessandro Oppo: could be consensus,

465
00:27:54,695 --> 00:27:57,015
Alessandro Oppo: could be a minority, it depends

466
00:27:57,420 --> 00:28:00,940
Alessandro Oppo: on the group and what they are trying to achieve.

467
00:28:01,340 --> 00:28:05,420
Alessandro Oppo: So I wonder like what could be like the design

468
00:28:06,060 --> 00:28:09,340
Alessandro Oppo: of something that works, let's say better than the

469
00:28:09,580 --> 00:28:11,180
Alessandro Oppo: actual system that we have now,

470
00:28:12,025 --> 00:28:15,225
Alessandro Oppo: the different form of representative democracy basically.

471
00:28:16,025 --> 00:28:17,785
John Gastil: Sure, sure. So

472
00:28:18,505 --> 00:28:21,225
John Gastil: I'll give a more specific answer,

473
00:28:21,305 --> 00:28:22,905
John Gastil: I'm speaking in general,

474
00:28:23,385 --> 00:28:24,345
John Gastil: almost sociological

475
00:28:24,345 --> 00:28:25,305
John Gastil: terms I suppose,

476
00:28:26,190 --> 00:28:32,824
John Gastil: but I'll give a more specific answer. So the last several years, I've been focusing more of my energy on something I

477
00:28:32,824 --> 00:28:34,030
call the democracy machine

478
00:28:34,670 --> 00:28:35,470
John Gastil: project,

479
00:28:36,030 --> 00:28:38,190
John Gastil: and the phrase democracy machine

480
00:28:38,915 --> 00:28:43,075
John Gastil: really honestly started as a joke at a talk I gave in Silicon Valley,

481
00:28:43,555 --> 00:28:46,515
John Gastil: someone, a friend of mine was supposed to give a talk for a democracy

482
00:28:46,835 --> 00:28:47,715
John Gastil: foundation,

483
00:28:47,955 --> 00:28:53,647
John Gastil: and she really didn't want to, so she asked if I would do it, and so I said, sure, and I wrote

484
00:28:53,647 --> 00:28:59,338
up some slides and I've been playing a lot of online games and mobile app games just to try to get my

485
00:28:59,338 --> 00:29:02,960
head back in that space because I think there is something interesting about gaming

486
00:29:03,120 --> 00:29:04,080
John Gastil: and deliberation,

487
00:29:04,275 --> 00:29:08,115
John Gastil: and so I gave this talk and I talked about this idea of a democracy machine,

488
00:29:08,595 --> 00:29:09,955
John Gastil: which caught on,

489
00:29:10,275 --> 00:29:16,133
John Gastil: and some people hate that term, some people loved it, and I thought, well, people are reacting to it, so my book

490
00:29:16,133 --> 00:29:18,530
coming out next year is going to be Democracy

491
00:29:18,530 --> 00:29:21,570
John Gastil: Machine is in the title, and you can find the project online,

492
00:29:22,050 --> 00:29:24,290
John Gastil: but the point is that

493
00:29:24,930 --> 00:29:27,250
John Gastil: one of the things we can very much improve

494
00:29:27,890 --> 00:29:28,690
John Gastil: is

495
00:29:28,850 --> 00:29:31,170
John Gastil: giving people like yourself and me

496
00:29:31,815 --> 00:29:35,815
John Gastil: and anyone else who has any interest in local affairs

497
00:29:36,455 --> 00:29:40,215
John Gastil: more of a role and a voice is local decision making.

498
00:29:40,535 --> 00:29:44,375
John Gastil: Why do I focus on local, like the town, the city, maybe the county?

499
00:29:46,010 --> 00:29:47,050
John Gastil: It's

500
00:29:47,050 --> 00:29:50,570
John Gastil: really much easier to have voice at the local level.

501
00:29:51,130 --> 00:29:54,570
John Gastil: The stakes aren't as high. It's hard to solve climate change

502
00:29:54,730 --> 00:29:56,490
John Gastil: in, you know, a single town,

503
00:29:57,690 --> 00:30:02,215
John Gastil: but you can do things in that town. You can meet the mayor, you can

504
00:30:02,615 --> 00:30:05,735
John Gastil: see the hole in the street that needs to be repaired,

505
00:30:06,455 --> 00:30:07,255
John Gastil: and

506
00:30:07,575 --> 00:30:13,819
John Gastil: know, interact with the city and do something about it. You can clean up a park where kids could play, You can

507
00:30:13,819 --> 00:30:16,090
do meaningful things that change your daily life.

508
00:30:17,050 --> 00:30:19,130
John Gastil: Now, I think digital technology

509
00:30:19,450 --> 00:30:21,450
John Gastil: has a powerful role to play in that.

510
00:30:22,090 --> 00:30:26,250
John Gastil: The internet right now is sometimes thought of as kind of the enemy of democracy

511
00:30:26,935 --> 00:30:30,215
John Gastil: because so many bad things happen online, right?

512
00:30:30,615 --> 00:30:34,935
John Gastil: This is why we can't have nice things on the internet. You've probably heard the term

513
00:30:35,255 --> 00:30:36,935
John Gastil: from Cory Doctorow,

514
00:30:37,255 --> 00:30:38,215
John Gastil: Enshitification,

515
00:30:38,790 --> 00:30:42,070
John Gastil: that everything becomes, excuse me, shitty

516
00:30:43,110 --> 00:30:49,541
John Gastil: over time when it's owned by a corporation, it starts out as fun, and pretty soon it just becomes maximized for profit,

517
00:30:49,541 --> 00:30:50,710
and we hate it.

518
00:30:51,925 --> 00:30:54,805
John Gastil: That's a very unfortunate but common pattern. Well,

519
00:30:55,205 --> 00:31:01,525
John Gastil: the digital technology that we have that connects everyday citizens with their local governments is very poor.

520
00:31:02,485 --> 00:31:09,786
John Gastil: Some cities have made a real effort to have some interactive websites, but there's nothing really sustained and deliberate of going

521
00:31:09,786 --> 00:31:17,434
on, and that's a total shame. I think there's a real opportunity there. Now, where digital games come in is I am

522
00:31:17,434 --> 00:31:19,520
not afraid of the word gamification.

523
00:31:20,445 --> 00:31:23,405
John Gastil: I like how many syllables it has. That's fun.

524
00:31:24,445 --> 00:31:28,445
John Gastil: You know, it's not gonna help you with Wordle where you only get a few letters,

525
00:31:28,605 --> 00:31:29,405
John Gastil: but

526
00:31:30,445 --> 00:31:31,245
John Gastil: gamification

527
00:31:31,245 --> 00:31:32,525
John Gastil: means take something

528
00:31:33,310 --> 00:31:39,230
John Gastil: and improve it by using lessons from game design. It doesn't mean make everything into a game,

529
00:31:39,630 --> 00:31:43,710
John Gastil: but what do games teach us? Well, one of the things they teach us is

530
00:31:44,510 --> 00:31:46,350
John Gastil: it's great if you know the objective,

531
00:31:47,075 --> 00:31:54,188
John Gastil: and it's great if those objectives kind of come and go, that is there's something that needs to be done this month,

532
00:31:54,188 --> 00:31:54,988
this week,

533
00:31:55,155 --> 00:31:58,355
John Gastil: let's get it done and then now there's something new we need to do.

534
00:31:59,270 --> 00:32:05,091
John Gastil: When you're playing a game, it's very confusing if someone has explained the game to you and you're still not sure what

535
00:32:05,091 --> 00:32:06,150
you're supposed to do

536
00:32:06,470 --> 00:32:11,670
John Gastil: or if there's only one objective and as far as you can tell, it's seven hours away

537
00:32:11,910 --> 00:32:14,630
John Gastil: and you thought you were gonna play a board game for thirty minutes.

538
00:32:15,635 --> 00:32:18,035
John Gastil: That kind of thing is very discouraging,

539
00:32:18,275 --> 00:32:21,795
John Gastil: it's the reason why some people never play board games again,

540
00:32:23,155 --> 00:32:28,355
John Gastil: but when I get recruited into an online opportunity to interact with my city government,

541
00:32:29,360 --> 00:32:34,542
John Gastil: I would like that. I would like to know what is the thing we're doing. What is our objective? What are we

542
00:32:34,542 --> 00:32:37,840
trying to do? And then when we reach the deadline, we make a decision.

543
00:32:38,160 --> 00:32:39,920
John Gastil: I get to see a consequence,

544
00:32:40,880 --> 00:32:43,360
John Gastil: and now there's something else we might turn our attention to.

545
00:32:44,385 --> 00:32:47,825
John Gastil: It's just one small example, but there's so many ways in which

546
00:32:48,145 --> 00:32:53,105
John Gastil: we actually, to quote Josh Lerner, one of my colleagues, we can make democracy fun,

547
00:32:53,345 --> 00:32:54,545
John Gastil: we really can.

548
00:32:54,785 --> 00:32:58,065
John Gastil: That doesn't mean that the issues are trivial or silly,

549
00:32:58,385 --> 00:33:01,500
John Gastil: it just means that we really could enjoy

550
00:33:01,580 --> 00:33:04,380
John Gastil: the process of working together, deliberating,

551
00:33:04,540 --> 00:33:08,220
John Gastil: it doesn't all have to be pain and power struggles,

552
00:33:08,940 --> 00:33:16,107
John Gastil: so that's one example of where I think we can maybe start to change, in this case, some of the digital structures

553
00:33:16,107 --> 00:33:19,365
we live in to change the way we do democracy.

554
00:33:19,765 --> 00:33:22,325
Alessandro Oppo: Yeah. I I was thinking about the relationship of,

555
00:33:23,045 --> 00:33:25,205
Alessandro Oppo: yeah, deliberation and and gaming.

556
00:33:25,925 --> 00:33:26,725
Alessandro Oppo: And,

557
00:33:26,760 --> 00:33:32,120
Alessandro Oppo: I mean, nowadays, I'm not playing anymore, but in the past, I played a little bit. Yeah. I know.

558
00:33:33,000 --> 00:33:40,170
John Gastil: Yeah. Have to study. Get to ask I get to ask a question. Board games, video games, or or more sports? What

559
00:33:40,170 --> 00:33:41,800
what was your preferred gaming?

560
00:33:43,825 --> 00:33:50,034
Alessandro Oppo: Now I would say probably more sports because I see that if I have to sit down a lot of time because

561
00:33:50,034 --> 00:33:53,985
I have to study or to do other things, then I prefer like to

562
00:33:55,185 --> 00:33:56,305
Alessandro Oppo: not sit down.

563
00:33:56,625 --> 00:33:59,860
John Gastil: Oh, I just I just lost your audio suddenly.

564
00:34:00,420 --> 00:34:03,940
John Gastil: Oh, no. Okay. There you go. There you go. Yeah. So you're playing...

565
00:34:04,580 --> 00:34:06,500
John Gastil: Is that football or or

566
00:34:07,300 --> 00:34:09,860
Alessandro Oppo: Football. I was really into table tennis.

567
00:34:10,775 --> 00:34:12,055
John Gastil: Oh, fantastic.

568
00:34:12,455 --> 00:34:13,335
John Gastil: That's great.

569
00:34:13,815 --> 00:34:15,655
John Gastil: Yeah, no, it's great. It's physical,

570
00:34:15,815 --> 00:34:19,815
John Gastil: but notice something about one of the things I like about table tennis,

571
00:34:19,895 --> 00:34:21,415
John Gastil: and tennis in general,

572
00:34:21,815 --> 00:34:25,210
John Gastil: is that you decide how many games to play.

573
00:34:25,530 --> 00:34:32,810
John Gastil: It's not just one three hour game, right? Oh my god, no, you play to eleven or 21 or whatever,

574
00:34:33,690 --> 00:34:35,530
John Gastil: and then you can decide to play a new

575
00:34:36,495 --> 00:34:38,975
John Gastil: It understands that there's a nice rhythm,

576
00:34:39,055 --> 00:34:42,095
John Gastil: and just like in tennis, a game is over pretty quickly,

577
00:34:42,415 --> 00:34:45,615
John Gastil: oh my gosh, the set's gonna take a while, the match could take forever,

578
00:34:46,095 --> 00:34:47,455
John Gastil: so you get to choose

579
00:34:47,695 --> 00:34:50,575
John Gastil: how to set the rules, and let me give you just one more example,

580
00:34:51,310 --> 00:34:55,630
John Gastil: we actually, a dear friend of mine named Mark Forehand,

581
00:34:55,790 --> 00:35:00,590
John Gastil: yes, we would play tennis together and Forehand obviously is something you have in tennis, but that's his real name,

582
00:35:02,030 --> 00:35:04,750
John Gastil: he and I would play tennis together, but he was very competitive

583
00:35:05,445 --> 00:35:08,965
John Gastil: and he recognized it could become a problem,

584
00:35:09,365 --> 00:35:14,485
John Gastil: and so instead of playing tennis, we invented a game we called Zen Buddhism,

585
00:35:14,965 --> 00:35:16,245
John Gastil: and in Zenith,

586
00:35:16,405 --> 00:35:17,205
John Gastil: you rally,

587
00:35:18,070 --> 00:35:19,990
John Gastil: but you're trying to hit a winner,

588
00:35:20,870 --> 00:35:27,763
John Gastil: and you collectively get a point if someone hits a winner, a point that a great shot the other person couldn't get

589
00:35:27,763 --> 00:35:28,563
back, impossible.

590
00:35:29,190 --> 00:35:32,230
John Gastil: You both lose a point if anything else happens,

591
00:35:33,745 --> 00:35:38,465
John Gastil: and your score at the end is how many errors it took to reach 10 winners.

592
00:35:38,785 --> 00:35:43,265
John Gastil: So like a score of 20, not bad. A score of 10 is incredible,

593
00:35:43,825 --> 00:35:48,065
John Gastil: and then we transferred that to table tennis, and mostly what we played is Zenith

594
00:35:48,450 --> 00:35:50,050
John Gastil: at the table tennis,

595
00:35:50,450 --> 00:35:52,770
John Gastil: but look at what that does to the game.

596
00:35:52,930 --> 00:35:57,090
John Gastil: It takes a competitive game and it makes it into a cooperative activity,

597
00:35:57,170 --> 00:36:01,250
John Gastil: but it's complex because the cooperative activity requires competition

598
00:36:01,810 --> 00:36:03,490
John Gastil: because otherwise you never get a winner,

599
00:36:04,705 --> 00:36:11,956
John Gastil: So, my point is just, so let's take that, you know, the one game you chose, I have no prior knowledge, I

600
00:36:11,956 --> 00:36:12,945
promise, dear listener,

601
00:36:13,985 --> 00:36:18,530
John Gastil: and it's so easy to restructure it and make it different,

602
00:36:19,170 --> 00:36:23,170
John Gastil: and have different social outcomes. Mark and I love playing together.

603
00:36:23,490 --> 00:36:24,690
John Gastil: If we competed,

604
00:36:24,850 --> 00:36:26,290
John Gastil: maybe not.

605
00:36:27,170 --> 00:36:29,730
John Gastil: Maybe we wouldn't still be friends to this day.

606
00:36:30,370 --> 00:36:32,485
Alessandro Oppo: Yeah. This is very

607
00:36:32,725 --> 00:36:39,630
Alessandro Oppo: true because I also felt the same, like with table tennis, sometimes I don't like to play a match, but just to,

608
00:36:39,630 --> 00:36:40,885
let's say, to train,

609
00:36:41,125 --> 00:36:42,485
Alessandro Oppo: because I feel like that,

610
00:36:42,645 --> 00:36:44,165
Alessandro Oppo: or someone ruined my day,

611
00:36:45,140 --> 00:36:46,340
Alessandro Oppo: or I will

612
00:36:46,740 --> 00:36:48,580
Alessandro Oppo: ruin the day off of someone else.

613
00:36:50,100 --> 00:36:51,060
Alessandro Oppo: Yes. Yes.

614
00:36:51,540 --> 00:36:52,340
Alessandro Oppo: Yeah.

615
00:36:52,980 --> 00:36:53,780
John Gastil: And

616
00:36:54,580 --> 00:36:55,780
John Gastil: also look at,

617
00:36:56,180 --> 00:37:01,635
John Gastil: we can move on to something else, but I do think these examples can be really powerful illustrations.

618
00:37:01,795 --> 00:37:02,595
John Gastil: So,

619
00:37:02,595 --> 00:37:04,355
John Gastil: in tennis, you

620
00:37:04,755 --> 00:37:08,995
John Gastil: have to call whether the ball is in or out, and arguments can happen and so on.

621
00:37:09,395 --> 00:37:14,115
John Gastil: You would think in table tennis, you always know whether the ball hit the table or not because

622
00:37:14,410 --> 00:37:15,290
John Gastil: there's no...

623
00:37:16,010 --> 00:37:21,450
John Gastil: It's either there's a table or nothing, right? In tennis, the ball just hit outside the... But you and I both know,

624
00:37:21,770 --> 00:37:22,570
John Gastil: Oh, no.

625
00:37:22,970 --> 00:37:25,850
John Gastil: There is that situation where the ball may have hit,

626
00:37:26,435 --> 00:37:32,841
John Gastil: barely hit the edge of the table, its movement barely moved, and the other person may say it was out, and you

627
00:37:32,841 --> 00:37:33,715
get upset because

628
00:37:33,875 --> 00:37:39,832
John Gastil: you're sure it hit the table. Well, in Zenith, that's not really a problem. You're making a collective judgment. You both want

629
00:37:39,832 --> 00:37:40,915
to get it right.

630
00:37:42,230 --> 00:37:45,590
John Gastil: Maybe you're biased in favor of yourselves together

631
00:37:45,750 --> 00:37:49,910
John Gastil: or maybe you're very tough on yourselves, you know, it doesn't really matter,

632
00:37:50,230 --> 00:37:54,550
John Gastil: the point is you have a shared goal so you make judgment differently

633
00:37:54,825 --> 00:37:57,705
John Gastil: and there shouldn't really be any reason to quarrel.

634
00:37:58,025 --> 00:38:00,265
John Gastil: So again, change the rules slightly

635
00:38:00,345 --> 00:38:03,145
John Gastil: and we just see very different social dynamics

636
00:38:03,145 --> 00:38:05,385
John Gastil: and different moods afterwards,

637
00:38:05,705 --> 00:38:10,812
John Gastil: you know. I will tell you Mark and I played this for years together when we were both in Seattle, I mean

638
00:38:10,812 --> 00:38:11,740
for a dozen years,

639
00:38:12,460 --> 00:38:15,180
John Gastil: I think once or possibly twice

640
00:38:15,260 --> 00:38:16,860
John Gastil: we had a perfect score,

641
00:38:17,100 --> 00:38:19,820
John Gastil: that is we made 10 winners with no errors,

642
00:38:21,020 --> 00:38:28,815
John Gastil: but I guarantee you maybe 15, 20, 30 times we had eight winners and no errors and then somebody screwed up,

643
00:38:29,855 --> 00:38:35,901
John Gastil: but I don't remember who screwed up, all I remember is we were so close to a perfect 10 winners with no

644
00:38:35,901 --> 00:38:36,701
errors,

645
00:38:36,735 --> 00:38:39,295
John Gastil: but the you know, the failure was shared

646
00:38:39,580 --> 00:38:43,420
John Gastil: and we would laugh about it instead of being frustrated.

647
00:38:43,900 --> 00:38:44,700
Alessandro Oppo: I

648
00:38:44,700 --> 00:38:46,780
Alessandro Oppo: was thinking that as an exercise

649
00:38:46,860 --> 00:38:48,860
Alessandro Oppo: is like super cool.

650
00:38:49,100 --> 00:38:50,940
Alessandro Oppo: Also sometimes with chess,

651
00:38:51,100 --> 00:38:52,460
Alessandro Oppo: I try to, let's say,

652
00:38:53,985 --> 00:38:58,145
Alessandro Oppo: to change the risk to see if we were able to play a different game.

653
00:38:58,545 --> 00:39:00,625
Alessandro Oppo: Because also I thought that most

654
00:39:00,945 --> 00:39:02,785
Alessandro Oppo: of the games in society,

655
00:39:02,945 --> 00:39:04,865
Alessandro Oppo: usually they're competitive,

656
00:39:06,465 --> 00:39:07,265
Alessandro Oppo: and

657
00:39:07,265 --> 00:39:10,520
Alessandro Oppo: I still don't have a clear idea about if that

658
00:39:11,880 --> 00:39:12,920
Alessandro Oppo: competitiveness...

659
00:39:13,480 --> 00:39:14,520
Alessandro Oppo: Yeah. I don't know.

660
00:39:15,400 --> 00:39:20,200
Alessandro Oppo: Is it like a sort of things that we have and it's good to,

661
00:39:20,840 --> 00:39:22,840
Alessandro Oppo: let's say, use in a game?

662
00:39:23,160 --> 00:39:28,535
Alessandro Oppo: So not in, let's say, in the real world, I mean, also game is in the real world,

663
00:39:29,735 --> 00:39:35,895
Alessandro Oppo: or if to compete in a game also train us to also compete

664
00:39:36,135 --> 00:39:36,935
Alessandro Oppo: outside

665
00:39:36,935 --> 00:39:37,735
Alessandro Oppo: of the game.

666
00:39:40,400 --> 00:39:41,680
Alessandro Oppo: Wonder about So the educational

667
00:39:42,960 --> 00:39:44,720
John Gastil: a couple things. One is

668
00:39:46,000 --> 00:39:49,040
John Gastil: you and I grew up in a world that believed

669
00:39:49,280 --> 00:39:50,080
John Gastil: that

670
00:39:50,560 --> 00:39:53,360
John Gastil: evolutionary biology was the story of competition,

671
00:39:53,705 --> 00:39:55,385
John Gastil: survival of the fittest,

672
00:39:55,545 --> 00:39:57,705
John Gastil: right? But in our lifetimes,

673
00:39:58,985 --> 00:39:59,785
John Gastil: evolutionary

674
00:40:01,545 --> 00:40:02,345
John Gastil: research

675
00:40:02,425 --> 00:40:06,425
John Gastil: has come to suggest it's much more complex than that, particularly with humans,

676
00:40:07,530 --> 00:40:10,570
John Gastil: that we appear to have selected for cooperation

677
00:40:10,570 --> 00:40:11,690
John Gastil: and community.

678
00:40:12,810 --> 00:40:13,610
John Gastil: Absolutely,

679
00:40:13,610 --> 00:40:14,410
John Gastil: early

680
00:40:14,410 --> 00:40:15,530
John Gastil: pre history

681
00:40:15,690 --> 00:40:19,050
John Gastil: humans absolutely would fight each other, kill each other,

682
00:40:19,530 --> 00:40:22,170
John Gastil: but you were never gonna survive if you didn't build a community.

683
00:40:22,855 --> 00:40:25,895
John Gastil: You had to build some kind of

684
00:40:26,775 --> 00:40:30,135
John Gastil: band that's bigger than your biological

685
00:40:30,135 --> 00:40:31,415
John Gastil: immediate family

686
00:40:31,495 --> 00:40:35,015
John Gastil: to thrive, and so we selected for people who can get along,

687
00:40:35,830 --> 00:40:39,270
John Gastil: and so we have these conflicting impulses, that competitive

688
00:40:39,270 --> 00:40:40,790
John Gastil: and that cooperative

689
00:40:41,430 --> 00:40:43,670
John Gastil: kind of impulse is in our

690
00:40:44,230 --> 00:40:45,590
John Gastil: DNA, if you will,

691
00:40:46,870 --> 00:40:47,670
John Gastil: and

692
00:40:47,830 --> 00:40:49,670
John Gastil: when it comes to modern

693
00:40:49,670 --> 00:40:50,470
John Gastil: society,

694
00:40:51,325 --> 00:40:54,125
John Gastil: I still think partly because of capitalism,

695
00:40:54,365 --> 00:40:59,165
John Gastil: there's a very strong ethos of competition as being natural and appropriate.

696
00:40:59,405 --> 00:41:04,045
John Gastil: There's a book that's now quite old, but it was a wonderful summary of the research and an argument

697
00:41:04,720 --> 00:41:07,600
John Gastil: called No Contest by Alfie Cohn,

698
00:41:07,920 --> 00:41:10,800
John Gastil: and it's kind of a popular social science book,

699
00:41:11,120 --> 00:41:15,520
John Gastil: but it really lays out the argument really well for how damaging competition can be,

700
00:41:16,915 --> 00:41:23,075
John Gastil: and I think Norway is the country that has been one of the most successful Olympic countries

701
00:41:23,075 --> 00:41:24,275
John Gastil: per capita

702
00:41:24,595 --> 00:41:25,715
John Gastil: in history,

703
00:41:26,435 --> 00:41:33,495
John Gastil: and I'm pretty sure you don't play competitive sports until after the age of 14. You're supposed to just play everything, just

704
00:41:33,495 --> 00:41:35,100
have fun, and it's organized

705
00:41:35,500 --> 00:41:41,836
John Gastil: kind of, but in The United States, I mean, we're putting you on specialized teams that travel the country at like the

706
00:41:41,836 --> 00:41:42,700
age of 10,

707
00:41:43,660 --> 00:41:49,395
John Gastil: and very often, you know, kids totally lose interest in sports. They they become anxious, bitter,

708
00:41:49,555 --> 00:41:53,795
John Gastil: they fight with their parents who are enforcing, you know, it's crazy,

709
00:41:54,515 --> 00:42:00,056
John Gastil: and so we really do need to think about that balance, but I do see a bit of a culture shift, and

710
00:42:00,056 --> 00:42:01,315
now this is very nerdy,

711
00:42:01,760 --> 00:42:03,760
John Gastil: but when it comes to board gaming,

712
00:42:04,720 --> 00:42:09,600
John Gastil: when I was a kid, we really didn't have very good cooperative games.

713
00:42:10,080 --> 00:42:12,960
John Gastil: There weren't many, even on the playground there weren't really many.

714
00:42:13,440 --> 00:42:14,640
John Gastil: Now it's a whole industry,

715
00:42:15,185 --> 00:42:20,545
John Gastil: right? Really good cooperative games like Pandemic is a famous one, which came out before COVID.

716
00:42:21,105 --> 00:42:23,505
John Gastil: I think it was more popular before COVID,

717
00:42:24,385 --> 00:42:29,345
John Gastil: but so many other games. There's a great Lord of the Rings game, right? Can you get to Mount Doom at time?

718
00:42:30,750 --> 00:42:34,590
John Gastil: And you know, what those cooperative games tend to have in common

719
00:42:34,830 --> 00:42:36,670
John Gastil: is some common enemy,

720
00:42:36,910 --> 00:42:38,590
John Gastil: some public problem.

721
00:42:40,030 --> 00:42:46,470
John Gastil: One, there's a really good firefighting game where you're all working together to try to put out a fire at a building

722
00:42:46,470 --> 00:42:50,275
or a house, and you each have different skills and abilities and equipment.

723
00:42:51,075 --> 00:42:55,635
John Gastil: The common enemy is fire, right? Lord of the Rings, obviously, it's the Dark Lord Sauron,

724
00:42:56,755 --> 00:42:57,635
John Gastil: and in

725
00:42:57,795 --> 00:43:00,650
John Gastil: a pandemic, obviously, is a pandemic,

726
00:43:01,450 --> 00:43:03,850
John Gastil: but when we do deliberation,

727
00:43:05,370 --> 00:43:11,988
John Gastil: again, back to the symbolic convergence, what is the work we're doing together? Usually there is some kind of common enemy we're

728
00:43:11,988 --> 00:43:12,890
trying to vanquish,

729
00:43:13,530 --> 00:43:14,650
John Gastil: and it's

730
00:43:14,665 --> 00:43:15,785
John Gastil: to some extent,

731
00:43:16,025 --> 00:43:17,465
John Gastil: I mean, sounds weird,

732
00:43:17,865 --> 00:43:22,345
John Gastil: but we're trying to overcome kind of ignorance and our own foolishness,

733
00:43:22,665 --> 00:43:23,465
John Gastil: that is,

734
00:43:24,425 --> 00:43:25,225
John Gastil: unfortunately,

735
00:43:25,225 --> 00:43:28,745
John Gastil: humans often make decisions with terrible unintended consequences,

736
00:43:28,905 --> 00:43:30,025
John Gastil: and we're trying to avoid that.

737
00:43:31,060 --> 00:43:35,300
John Gastil: We're also usually trying to tackle a problem that is really tough. It's poverty,

738
00:43:35,380 --> 00:43:36,740
John Gastil: it's climate change,

739
00:43:37,300 --> 00:43:38,100
John Gastil: it's

740
00:43:38,580 --> 00:43:45,780
John Gastil: bad health outcomes, right? What can we do together to help tackle this problem and overcome our own weaknesses, our own biases,

741
00:43:46,275 --> 00:43:47,635
John Gastil: our own ignorance

742
00:43:48,595 --> 00:43:49,395
John Gastil: and

743
00:43:49,475 --> 00:43:56,592
John Gastil: that is where people kind of band together. Now, don't think we do a great job of managing that kind of symbolic

744
00:43:56,592 --> 00:43:57,392
aspect,

745
00:43:57,875 --> 00:44:01,795
John Gastil: but I think that's one of the things we can play with in digital technology

746
00:44:02,030 --> 00:44:04,110
John Gastil: and we can start to reinforce

747
00:44:04,110 --> 00:44:05,310
John Gastil: your identity.

748
00:44:05,470 --> 00:44:06,590
John Gastil: So for example,

749
00:44:06,990 --> 00:44:09,390
John Gastil: you might get a badge that says,

750
00:44:09,550 --> 00:44:15,870
John Gastil: one of the things you're really good at is bringing up contrary points of view, not to disrupt the discussion,

751
00:44:16,030 --> 00:44:22,694
John Gastil: but to enrich it, and you now start to feel proud about that like, hey, this is this is one of my

752
00:44:22,694 --> 00:44:29,359
special roles. This is what I do. Someone else is famous for finding factual information that maybe was missing when we started

753
00:44:29,359 --> 00:44:30,159
the deliberation.

754
00:44:30,260 --> 00:44:37,759
John Gastil: They're the nerdiest nerd in our group and we love them for it, right? Sometimes they bring up information that doesn't seem

755
00:44:37,759 --> 00:44:38,559
genuinely

756
00:44:38,100 --> 00:44:38,900
John Gastil: relevant,

757
00:44:39,060 --> 00:44:42,660
John Gastil: but we don't want to discourage them because we, you know, you get the point,

758
00:44:43,060 --> 00:44:44,660
John Gastil: and that we start to now,

759
00:44:45,045 --> 00:44:51,765
John Gastil: if you've ever played Dungeons and Dragons or any of the other fine role playing games, aren't official D and D,

760
00:44:52,965 --> 00:44:54,165
John Gastil: you'll recognize

761
00:44:54,485 --> 00:44:56,805
John Gastil: that, oh, this is the cleric, the thief,

762
00:44:58,030 --> 00:44:59,790
John Gastil: the, you know, swords person,

763
00:45:00,350 --> 00:45:05,470
John Gastil: you know, the monk, and so on. Sorry for the wizards and magic users. I didn't mean to forget you.

764
00:45:06,510 --> 00:45:10,925
John Gastil: That, you know, and then what do they all have? They have a story, right? And so,

765
00:45:11,325 --> 00:45:17,405
John Gastil: you know, that idea of complementary skills banding together, it's an old story, and we love that story,

766
00:45:18,125 --> 00:45:19,325
John Gastil: but it's funny

767
00:45:19,725 --> 00:45:27,471
John Gastil: how often we forget that some of the best stories in human history are groups and communities banding together as opposed to

768
00:45:27,471 --> 00:45:30,640
great individuals that did great and often terrible things.

769
00:45:31,280 --> 00:45:34,960
Alessandro Oppo: Yeah, I was thinking about these things about collaborating

770
00:45:34,960 --> 00:45:35,760
Alessandro Oppo: and compete.

771
00:45:36,385 --> 00:45:39,265
Alessandro Oppo: Because also as you said, let's say that we are working,

772
00:45:41,185 --> 00:45:42,305
Alessandro Oppo: we see the

773
00:45:43,025 --> 00:45:45,825
Alessandro Oppo: symbolic convergence of let's say making

774
00:45:47,105 --> 00:45:51,505
Alessandro Oppo: better democracy in the future. And so at the same time, it's like

775
00:45:52,170 --> 00:45:54,010
Alessandro Oppo: competing with other kind of,

776
00:45:54,730 --> 00:45:58,010
Alessandro Oppo: I don't know, political system, possible political systems.

777
00:45:58,330 --> 00:46:01,290
Alessandro Oppo: So there is always this sort of conflict.

778
00:46:04,375 --> 00:46:07,495
Alessandro Oppo: And I was thinking that is also very related to,

779
00:46:08,215 --> 00:46:11,255
Alessandro Oppo: let's say, I don't know, a movement that could identify,

780
00:46:12,855 --> 00:46:18,775
Alessandro Oppo: you know, like internal enemy or external enemy that makes the group more united.

781
00:46:20,590 --> 00:46:22,750
John Gastil: Yeah, the tricky part is when that enemy

782
00:46:23,150 --> 00:46:24,030
John Gastil: becomes

783
00:46:24,590 --> 00:46:26,590
John Gastil: the other half of my society,

784
00:46:26,830 --> 00:46:31,950
John Gastil: and that's where everything breaks down, and that's what we have right now in The US and so many other countries.

785
00:46:33,125 --> 00:46:40,471
John Gastil: We unfortunately have chosen an electoral system that kind of makes it rational to have only two major parties. It's very hard

786
00:46:40,471 --> 00:46:41,271
otherwise.

787
00:46:42,245 --> 00:46:44,405
John Gastil: And that just encourages

788
00:46:44,405 --> 00:46:46,165
John Gastil: this exact division

789
00:46:46,270 --> 00:46:49,150
John Gastil: where my side good, your side bad,

790
00:46:50,430 --> 00:46:51,230
John Gastil: and

791
00:46:51,230 --> 00:46:56,510
John Gastil: that's not to say that the two sides are equal or share equal blame for our problems in our country, I don't

792
00:46:56,510 --> 00:46:57,470
believe that at all,

793
00:46:57,950 --> 00:47:01,150
John Gastil: but we have built our political system for division.

794
00:47:01,925 --> 00:47:03,605
John Gastil: That is its design,

795
00:47:04,645 --> 00:47:06,805
John Gastil: and I think that's a mistake. Now,

796
00:47:07,845 --> 00:47:14,468
John Gastil: some of my colleagues in The US will say, Well, I'm jealous of these countries that are proportional representation and have multipart.

797
00:47:14,468 --> 00:47:21,091
Well, Italy and Israel can tell you something about, you know, that doesn't always work, right? You can sometimes have trouble finding

798
00:47:21,091 --> 00:47:27,714
a government, right? Forming a majority. Israel is about to experience that yet again, right? So, you know, there are all sorts

799
00:47:27,714 --> 00:47:33,735
of ways of thinking about this. I do want to plug two very different books here. One is a classic.

800
00:47:33,975 --> 00:47:37,095
John Gastil: So I was a graduate student from 1989

801
00:47:37,095 --> 00:47:38,455
John Gastil: to 1994,

802
00:47:38,855 --> 00:47:41,255
John Gastil: and that was just a few years after

803
00:47:41,495 --> 00:47:44,455
John Gastil: Beyond Adversary Democracy by Jane Mansbridge,

804
00:47:45,650 --> 00:47:52,690
John Gastil: and she basically makes points that you're hearing in all of my talk about unitary democracy and adversarial

805
00:47:52,690 --> 00:47:53,570
John Gastil: democracy,

806
00:47:54,610 --> 00:47:55,810
John Gastil: and it's

807
00:47:55,810 --> 00:48:01,868
John Gastil: that same kind of experience I had as a child, right? How much do we find how to reach consensus? How much

808
00:48:01,868 --> 00:48:07,926
do we disagree? And you need both. The core point of that book is you need both and if your system skews

809
00:48:07,926 --> 00:48:11,505
too far to one side or the other, you either become too adversarial

810
00:48:11,985 --> 00:48:12,785
John Gastil: or

811
00:48:12,865 --> 00:48:14,705
John Gastil: too monocultural,

812
00:48:14,705 --> 00:48:15,505
John Gastil: right?

813
00:48:16,000 --> 00:48:18,240
John Gastil: You know, one party rule isn't ever

814
00:48:18,640 --> 00:48:20,400
John Gastil: working well in democracy.

815
00:48:21,120 --> 00:48:24,080
John Gastil: Now, the very different book I'll recommend is more self serving.

816
00:48:24,800 --> 00:48:26,320
John Gastil: I did write a couple novels

817
00:48:26,320 --> 00:48:30,080
John Gastil: that both came out in 2020 and one is called Dungeon Party

818
00:48:30,545 --> 00:48:31,985
John Gastil: and it's fiction,

819
00:48:33,025 --> 00:48:38,785
John Gastil: it's about gaming, and it's about a group that participates in a game like Dungeons and Dragons.

820
00:48:39,025 --> 00:48:43,185
John Gastil: The point is that, yeah, it's a book about games and gaming and so on,

821
00:48:44,010 --> 00:48:46,330
John Gastil: but anyone who, like this conversation,

822
00:48:46,730 --> 00:48:48,330
John Gastil: you'll hear it in there,

823
00:48:49,130 --> 00:48:55,816
John Gastil: and it's not a fantasy book per se. It really is about people playing a game and the characters that they play

824
00:48:55,816 --> 00:49:00,375
in that game, and it's about how they deal with conflict, how they overcome adversity,

825
00:49:00,455 --> 00:49:04,935
John Gastil: how they potentially do or don't build a shared symbolic universe,

826
00:49:05,815 --> 00:49:09,735
John Gastil: and anyone who's been to a gaming convention, especially a smaller one,

827
00:49:10,810 --> 00:49:17,473
John Gastil: they will recognize that people are passionate about their games, they'll argue about the rules and so on, but they're also generally

828
00:49:17,473 --> 00:49:19,290
the sweetest people you'll ever meet.

829
00:49:19,770 --> 00:49:22,810
John Gastil: They're so kind, they're welcoming, they want you to come play the games,

830
00:49:23,645 --> 00:49:29,805
John Gastil: and they're incredibly inclusive for the most part. They've had their problems with gender and race and so on,

831
00:49:30,125 --> 00:49:32,525
John Gastil: but especially in the modern age,

832
00:49:33,165 --> 00:49:34,525
John Gastil: it's really remarkable,

833
00:49:34,525 --> 00:49:40,220
John Gastil: and so there's a group that shares a passion, they've learned how to work together, they have rules, they have organization,

834
00:49:40,620 --> 00:49:44,380
John Gastil: they don't think of themselves as a movement, but secretly they do,

835
00:49:45,340 --> 00:49:49,660
John Gastil: and I think we could learn something from how they deal with conflict and how they

836
00:49:50,365 --> 00:49:51,565
John Gastil: really master

837
00:49:51,565 --> 00:49:56,445
John Gastil: symbolic convergence in a way that sometimes we're so secular and so political

838
00:49:56,525 --> 00:49:57,405
John Gastil: that we

839
00:49:57,805 --> 00:50:01,965
John Gastil: kind of forget about the kind of the magic of forming community together,

840
00:50:02,525 --> 00:50:05,405
John Gastil: which really sets the stage for good deliberation.

841
00:50:06,180 --> 00:50:08,580
Alessandro Oppo: I was thinking about how,

842
00:50:09,060 --> 00:50:14,100
Alessandro Oppo: because I think one of the main problem that is quite recurrent is that democracy

843
00:50:15,540 --> 00:50:22,268
Alessandro Oppo: is not fun for most of the people. I mean, democracy, I mean, then it's not even true because, I mean, people

844
00:50:22,268 --> 00:50:28,385
argue maybe with their family, with their brother, with their friends, maybe they argue a lot all the night long,

845
00:50:28,785 --> 00:50:31,585
Alessandro Oppo: but then that is not, let's say, recorded

846
00:50:31,745 --> 00:50:32,545
Alessandro Oppo: in the...

847
00:50:35,160 --> 00:50:37,000
Alessandro Oppo: And so I was thinking because

848
00:50:37,160 --> 00:50:42,040
Alessandro Oppo: on one side, we could make like, I don't know, taking decisions and

849
00:50:42,920 --> 00:50:44,440
Alessandro Oppo: talking about issues,

850
00:50:45,320 --> 00:50:46,120
Alessandro Oppo: more fun.

851
00:50:46,745 --> 00:50:48,985
Alessandro Oppo: And on the other side also

852
00:50:48,985 --> 00:50:50,265
Alessandro Oppo: going where

853
00:50:51,865 --> 00:50:54,745
Alessandro Oppo: there are activities that are already fun for people.

854
00:50:55,065 --> 00:50:56,985
Alessandro Oppo: So it could be, I don't know,

855
00:50:58,185 --> 00:51:00,265
Alessandro Oppo: they play World of Warcraft online,

856
00:51:01,060 --> 00:51:02,260
Alessandro Oppo: and I

857
00:51:02,260 --> 00:51:03,380
Alessandro Oppo: don't know the...

858
00:51:03,700 --> 00:51:05,460
Alessandro Oppo: How do you call that? NPC,

859
00:51:05,540 --> 00:51:06,420
Alessandro Oppo: like the...

860
00:51:06,660 --> 00:51:07,460
Alessandro Oppo: Right.

861
00:51:07,620 --> 00:51:08,420
Alessandro Oppo: The...

862
00:51:09,700 --> 00:51:12,340
Alessandro Oppo: How it's it's called? Like, the artificial,

863
00:51:14,345 --> 00:51:20,505
Alessandro Oppo: like there is not behind a person. I'm just telling for people that are Artificial intelligence or like a chatbot or?

864
00:51:20,745 --> 00:51:22,185
Alessandro Oppo: No, like the non,

865
00:51:28,650 --> 00:51:33,050
Alessandro Oppo: how do you... Because usually, like, a person move their character, like the,

866
00:51:33,770 --> 00:51:39,301
Alessandro Oppo: I don't know, the human inside the the game, but then there are some that that are played by the game itself.

867
00:51:39,301 --> 00:51:40,810
Oh, non player characters? NPC? Exactly.

868
00:51:41,555 --> 00:51:43,235
Alessandro Oppo: Exactly the NPC. Yep.

869
00:51:44,115 --> 00:51:46,035
Alessandro Oppo: Maybe they could just,

870
00:51:47,155 --> 00:51:52,355
Alessandro Oppo: I don't know, because right now they are functional, what they suggest. I don't know, they ask you to take a decision,

871
00:51:52,755 --> 00:51:57,530
Alessandro Oppo: maybe there is a story. But I was thinking maybe they could be connected to real things.

872
00:51:57,930 --> 00:52:00,010
Alessandro Oppo: I don't know, let's say in Absolutely.

873
00:52:00,410 --> 00:52:06,096
Alessandro Oppo: There is a case in The US, and then people all around the world on World Warcraft, they click yes, I agree,

874
00:52:06,096 --> 00:52:07,130
disagree for this reason.

875
00:52:08,745 --> 00:52:11,545
John Gastil: Well, consider this for example. So,

876
00:52:12,185 --> 00:52:14,425
John Gastil: betting markets, prediction markets,

877
00:52:14,505 --> 00:52:15,945
John Gastil: Cauchy and so on,

878
00:52:16,345 --> 00:52:17,785
John Gastil: are incredibly popular,

879
00:52:18,585 --> 00:52:22,425
John Gastil: and there's, you know, a lot of people who love betting on sports,

880
00:52:22,585 --> 00:52:23,865
John Gastil: now they're betting on politics.

881
00:52:24,630 --> 00:52:26,390
John Gastil: Some of it is very problematic.

882
00:52:27,990 --> 00:52:30,310
John Gastil: There's also a successful

883
00:52:31,190 --> 00:52:32,950
John Gastil: micro lending culture,

884
00:52:34,070 --> 00:52:41,577
John Gastil: right, where very small loans in developing countries might let someone start an auto repair business. Maybe they only need the equivalent

885
00:52:41,577 --> 00:52:43,965
of like a thousand US dollars, right?

886
00:52:44,845 --> 00:52:48,045
John Gastil: But when we think of investment, we tend to think of investing in companies

887
00:52:48,605 --> 00:52:50,205
John Gastil: that are worth billions of dollars.

888
00:52:50,445 --> 00:52:51,485
John Gastil: Well, imagine

889
00:52:51,725 --> 00:52:54,925
John Gastil: if we could take the passion of the betting community,

890
00:52:55,380 --> 00:52:59,700
John Gastil: and you could essentially bet on by investing in small

891
00:52:59,860 --> 00:53:00,820
John Gastil: entrepreneurs

892
00:53:00,820 --> 00:53:01,780
John Gastil: and so on,

893
00:53:02,740 --> 00:53:09,193
John Gastil: and you could develop a reputation for having a very keen eye for what's a shrewd investment, and you could get all

894
00:53:09,193 --> 00:53:09,993
this status

895
00:53:10,095 --> 00:53:12,655
John Gastil: for it, but you're really building

896
00:53:13,295 --> 00:53:14,095
John Gastil: community.

897
00:53:14,095 --> 00:53:22,095
John Gastil: Now, it's not a big step to go from a successful small business like someone who's gonna sew clothes or repair

898
00:53:22,495 --> 00:53:23,295
John Gastil: machines

899
00:53:23,750 --> 00:53:26,150
John Gastil: to communities and community building,

900
00:53:26,230 --> 00:53:28,630
John Gastil: so now I want to reduce

901
00:53:28,870 --> 00:53:30,790
John Gastil: the rate of malaria

902
00:53:30,790 --> 00:53:31,990
John Gastil: in a community

903
00:53:32,150 --> 00:53:38,070
John Gastil: and I think I know the best investment to help do that. I think these medicines and these medical practices,

904
00:53:38,545 --> 00:53:41,665
John Gastil: partnering Western doctors with traditional healers,

905
00:53:41,825 --> 00:53:47,655
John Gastil: know, that's where I think the smart money is, that's where I'm placing my bets and I'm putting real money into that,

906
00:53:47,655 --> 00:53:50,305
meanwhile you disagree and you think this, you know, and

907
00:53:50,880 --> 00:53:53,280
John Gastil: there could be this sort of competitive

908
00:53:53,360 --> 00:53:54,160
John Gastil: fun

909
00:53:54,480 --> 00:53:55,280
John Gastil: in

910
00:53:55,520 --> 00:53:56,720
John Gastil: trying to

911
00:53:56,880 --> 00:53:57,760
John Gastil: optimize

912
00:53:57,760 --> 00:53:59,520
John Gastil: real social outcomes.

913
00:54:00,720 --> 00:54:06,700
John Gastil: The only key that all these things have in common is a measurable outcome, and sometimes I think we lack a little

914
00:54:06,700 --> 00:54:07,515
creativity about that.

915
00:54:08,475 --> 00:54:13,915
John Gastil: You don't want it to just rely on what some grad student rated that case as successful.

916
00:54:14,075 --> 00:54:17,115
John Gastil: No, you want some objective indicator like the infection rate

917
00:54:17,670 --> 00:54:22,390
John Gastil: or the poverty rate and so on. So I think we can get creative. In

918
00:54:22,790 --> 00:54:24,710
John Gastil: the Democracy Machine book,

919
00:54:25,430 --> 00:54:27,590
John Gastil: I'm trying to suggest

920
00:54:27,910 --> 00:54:34,625
John Gastil: how these sort of creative impulses can mix into real institutional design, but I don't pretend to have the solutions.

921
00:54:35,265 --> 00:54:36,785
John Gastil: I think that's the right approach,

922
00:54:37,585 --> 00:54:42,545
John Gastil: but every year, we're getting more and more creative with some of the things we can do digitally,

923
00:54:42,705 --> 00:54:49,772
John Gastil: and as problematic as AI is, I think AI is also, when well used, is going to be incredibly powerful to help

924
00:54:49,772 --> 00:54:51,700
us do some of these things.

925
00:54:52,580 --> 00:54:57,220
John Gastil: It's just a question of who controls it and how its benefits are distributed,

926
00:54:57,860 --> 00:55:00,980
John Gastil: but I don't think sending it away is gonna be the solution.

927
00:55:01,695 --> 00:55:03,455
Alessandro Oppo: No, absolutely. And also,

928
00:55:04,415 --> 00:55:06,015
Alessandro Oppo: let's say, very excited about

929
00:55:07,535 --> 00:55:09,215
Alessandro Oppo: how we can use AI

930
00:55:09,455 --> 00:55:13,375
Alessandro Oppo: for politics, and also worried about the concentration of power

931
00:55:13,535 --> 00:55:14,655
Alessandro Oppo: relation to AI.

932
00:55:15,090 --> 00:55:18,850
Alessandro Oppo: And I wanted to ask you, let's say we are, let's say, very creative

933
00:55:19,170 --> 00:55:20,530
Alessandro Oppo: and there's very,

934
00:55:21,410 --> 00:55:23,170
Alessandro Oppo: let's say, I don't know, positive,

935
00:55:23,970 --> 00:55:24,770
Alessandro Oppo: how

936
00:55:25,490 --> 00:55:32,873
Alessandro Oppo: it could look like the democracy of the future, let's say in ten or twenty years. Yeah. If everything goes well, no

937
00:55:32,873 --> 00:55:34,215
third world war, no

938
00:55:34,775 --> 00:55:38,295
Alessandro Oppo: no another pandemic, no Yeah. Natural disaster,

939
00:55:38,535 --> 00:55:39,575
Alessandro Oppo: and so on. Yeah.

940
00:55:40,855 --> 00:55:43,015
John Gastil: You know, I... It is so hard to forecast.

941
00:55:44,190 --> 00:55:46,110
John Gastil: My

942
00:55:46,270 --> 00:55:49,150
John Gastil: favorite sports team is the Detroit Lions

943
00:55:49,230 --> 00:55:54,795
John Gastil: American football team and if you ask me to forecast them this year, it will be of course they're gonna win the

944
00:55:54,795 --> 00:55:58,590
Super Bowl. If you asked me last year, I would give you the same answer.

945
00:55:59,805 --> 00:56:05,085
John Gastil: Every single year you will get that answer because I'm confident and irrational.

946
00:56:06,525 --> 00:56:10,205
John Gastil: Hey, they might. They have a good team, but if you ask me about politics,

947
00:56:10,285 --> 00:56:12,445
John Gastil: I'm reluctant to predict an outcome.

948
00:56:13,210 --> 00:56:16,970
John Gastil: I'm more interested in laying out the range of

949
00:56:17,370 --> 00:56:20,490
John Gastil: possible outcomes because we're making a choice together.

950
00:56:21,450 --> 00:56:24,330
John Gastil: You know, people who can forecast confidently

951
00:56:24,490 --> 00:56:26,650
John Gastil: are mostly wrong and unaccountable,

952
00:56:26,995 --> 00:56:29,475
John Gastil: right? We only remember the person who got it right,

953
00:56:30,515 --> 00:56:35,715
John Gastil: and so the thing I would stress is what you know living in Italy and I know living in The US,

954
00:56:35,955 --> 00:56:38,595
John Gastil: which is there are nightmare scenarios ahead of us

955
00:56:39,090 --> 00:56:41,570
John Gastil: where power gets even more concentrated.

956
00:56:42,130 --> 00:56:46,450
John Gastil: If you think we have inequality now, just you wait. It can get so much worse,

957
00:56:47,170 --> 00:56:49,170
John Gastil: but there really are other possibilities.

958
00:56:49,970 --> 00:56:52,050
John Gastil: We get excited when we see

959
00:56:53,170 --> 00:56:54,610
John Gastil: a student movement

960
00:56:54,825 --> 00:56:55,785
John Gastil: transform

961
00:56:55,785 --> 00:56:59,385
John Gastil: a government overnight, the public broadcaster apologizes

962
00:56:59,385 --> 00:57:04,105
John Gastil: for having lied for several years. These are exciting events happening right

963
00:57:04,105 --> 00:57:05,065
John Gastil: near Italy.

964
00:57:05,545 --> 00:57:10,920
John Gastil: I wish they were nearer to us. In our case, we see Canada suddenly rising in international

965
00:57:10,920 --> 00:57:11,720
John Gastil: leadership

966
00:57:11,800 --> 00:57:18,337
John Gastil: and saying, you know what, it's time to move on. There's a different vision for the world and it's one of collaboration

967
00:57:18,337 --> 00:57:20,120
and oh my god, it's inspiring.

968
00:57:20,200 --> 00:57:21,080
John Gastil: Well,

969
00:57:21,080 --> 00:57:25,305
John Gastil: you know, our system inspired that response in an unfortunate way,

970
00:57:25,865 --> 00:57:28,345
John Gastil: so there really are positive possibilities.

971
00:57:28,425 --> 00:57:29,225
John Gastil: Transformative

972
00:57:30,745 --> 00:57:33,385
John Gastil: and I know too many synods

973
00:57:33,545 --> 00:57:40,619
John Gastil: who say, well, we're doomed, we're doomed, and you know, our last chance was last year or five years ago or ten

974
00:57:40,619 --> 00:57:47,693
years ago or World War II or whatever, you know, they always make up some theory that explains why the outcome is

975
00:57:47,693 --> 00:57:50,265
inevitable and it's bad. Well, they're just wrong.

976
00:57:51,865 --> 00:57:56,345
John Gastil: Know, there's always hope. There's always the potential for transformation.

977
00:57:56,985 --> 00:57:57,865
John Gastil: If anything,

978
00:57:58,105 --> 00:58:00,985
John Gastil: sometimes the rate of change has accelerated,

979
00:58:02,050 --> 00:58:07,876
John Gastil: and so I think just the internet is the last example I'll give you and I want to say before we go,

980
00:58:07,876 --> 00:58:09,730
just how much I've enjoyed this conversation,

981
00:58:09,890 --> 00:58:11,330
John Gastil: I love how spontaneous

982
00:58:11,490 --> 00:58:14,610
John Gastil: these things are and we wind up talking about table tennis,

983
00:58:14,850 --> 00:58:15,650
John Gastil: you never know,

984
00:58:16,935 --> 00:58:20,935
John Gastil: but just take the internet. A colleague of mine at Stanford always

985
00:58:21,175 --> 00:58:21,975
John Gastil: says,

986
00:58:22,295 --> 00:58:24,455
John Gastil: the internet is younger than you think,

987
00:58:24,855 --> 00:58:27,815
John Gastil: right? We haven't really made decisions

988
00:58:27,815 --> 00:58:29,575
John Gastil: about how it works,

989
00:58:29,975 --> 00:58:32,910
John Gastil: about how to structure it. Facebook, Google,

990
00:58:33,150 --> 00:58:37,150
John Gastil: Apple, these things didn't exist like five seconds ago,

991
00:58:38,110 --> 00:58:42,750
John Gastil: and we've never really sat down as a country, as a world and said, what do we want?

992
00:58:43,470 --> 00:58:48,385
John Gastil: We've just sort of let the market go and let the capital concentrate,

993
00:58:48,705 --> 00:58:52,545
John Gastil: and now the EU in particular is starting to push back more.

994
00:58:52,705 --> 00:58:54,705
John Gastil: That may happen in my country as well,

995
00:58:55,105 --> 00:59:00,783
John Gastil: but it's not just about pushing back, I think it's about affirmatively making decisions. What do we want? How do we want

996
00:59:00,783 --> 00:59:03,880
to live together, and what can we do to make that better?

997
00:59:04,680 --> 00:59:09,320
John Gastil: So, I think we have a lot of good choices ahead of us. I just hope we make them.

998
00:59:09,640 --> 00:59:11,240
Alessandro Oppo: Yeah, hopefully, yes.

999
00:59:11,560 --> 00:59:12,360
Alessandro Oppo: But

1000
00:59:12,360 --> 00:59:14,680
Alessandro Oppo: I don't know, looking at history, sometimes I'm like,

1001
00:59:16,165 --> 00:59:17,925
Alessandro Oppo: I don't know. Like, sometimes

1002
00:59:18,965 --> 00:59:22,165
Alessandro Oppo: sometimes human don't really take good decisions,

1003
00:59:22,245 --> 00:59:23,045
Alessandro Oppo: but

1004
00:59:24,165 --> 00:59:26,805
John Gastil: Well, ask me how I feel next Wednesday after our elections.

1005
00:59:29,230 --> 00:59:35,070
John Gastil: I'll tell you this, my Brazilian colleagues are feeling a lot more optimistic about the future than they were two weeks ago,

1006
00:59:36,190 --> 00:59:38,830
John Gastil: so you know, I mean, you've

1007
00:59:38,910 --> 00:59:40,830
John Gastil: heard the phrase elections have consequences,

1008
00:59:41,215 --> 00:59:42,015
John Gastil: I mean,

1009
00:59:42,655 --> 00:59:43,855
John Gastil: does matter

1010
00:59:44,735 --> 00:59:47,135
John Gastil: and the choices we make are absolutely

1011
00:59:47,135 --> 00:59:48,255
John Gastil: consequential,

1012
00:59:49,135 --> 00:59:55,950
John Gastil: so, you know, every local election, every regional election, certainly every national election, every EU election, they all matter,

1013
00:59:55,950 --> 01:00:03,842
the stakes are real, what we have to hope is that we're organizing political movements that give us good choices on every

1014
01:00:03,842 --> 01:00:04,642
ballot.

1015
01:00:05,000 --> 01:00:07,240
John Gastil: We never want to just choose between

1016
01:00:07,480 --> 01:00:08,280
John Gastil: two

1017
01:00:08,565 --> 01:00:11,685
John Gastil: choices that are unexciting and uninspiring,

1018
01:00:11,765 --> 01:00:15,285
John Gastil: so that's part of the work of democracy is

1019
01:00:15,365 --> 01:00:18,725
John Gastil: really organizing people who are passionate about deliberation,

1020
01:00:18,725 --> 01:00:19,605
John Gastil: about progress,

1021
01:00:19,925 --> 01:00:22,005
John Gastil: and getting the message out effectively

1022
01:00:22,400 --> 01:00:26,960
John Gastil: and really encouraging people to make positive choices for our future.

1023
01:00:27,440 --> 01:00:29,760
Alessandro Oppo: Yeah, and also sometimes I think

1024
01:00:30,080 --> 01:00:31,360
Alessandro Oppo: that maybe

1025
01:00:31,760 --> 01:00:34,240
Alessandro Oppo: also the things about parties,

1026
01:00:34,240 --> 01:00:35,840
Alessandro Oppo: maybe we could

1027
01:00:38,115 --> 01:00:39,315
Alessandro Oppo: go over that,

1028
01:00:39,475 --> 01:00:41,635
Alessandro Oppo: but I don't know. Maybe in the future.

1029
01:00:41,875 --> 01:00:44,035
John Gastil: Maybe our next hour. Yes.

1030
01:00:45,075 --> 01:00:47,555
Alessandro Oppo: Can I? Last question and then Sure.

1031
01:00:48,035 --> 01:00:48,835
Alessandro Oppo: Okay.

1032
01:00:51,140 --> 01:00:51,940
Alessandro Oppo: I mean,

1033
01:00:52,740 --> 01:00:54,660
Alessandro Oppo: it's one question and alpha,

1034
01:00:54,980 --> 01:00:57,780
Alessandro Oppo: actually. Like, if you have any

1035
01:00:57,780 --> 01:00:59,940
Alessandro Oppo: open question regarding,

1036
01:00:59,940 --> 01:01:00,740
Alessandro Oppo: like,

1037
01:01:00,980 --> 01:01:03,380
Alessandro Oppo: politics, democracy, like something that

1038
01:01:03,620 --> 01:01:06,660
Alessandro Oppo: you're thinking a lot and

1039
01:01:06,065 --> 01:01:06,865
Alessandro Oppo: recently.

1040
01:01:07,265 --> 01:01:13,185
Alessandro Oppo: And also, if you have a final message for all the people that are working on democratic

1041
01:01:13,185 --> 01:01:14,945
Alessandro Oppo: innovation, political things.

1042
01:01:16,065 --> 01:01:16,865
John Gastil: Sure.

1043
01:01:17,425 --> 01:01:21,185
John Gastil: So I think one of the one of the most fun research questions,

1044
01:01:22,600 --> 01:01:26,680
John Gastil: and we haven't made a lot of progress on this, but I've seen a couple studies,

1045
01:01:27,880 --> 01:01:29,640
John Gastil: under what circumstances

1046
01:01:30,120 --> 01:01:31,240
John Gastil: can you

1047
01:01:31,400 --> 01:01:35,960
John Gastil: increase people's confidence in democracy and in the democratic process

1048
01:01:36,280 --> 01:01:37,400
John Gastil: even when they lose?

1049
01:01:38,435 --> 01:01:39,235
John Gastil: So

1050
01:01:39,395 --> 01:01:44,115
John Gastil: some of these questions, some of these issues really do come down to a majority vote.

1051
01:01:45,235 --> 01:01:46,915
John Gastil: I think the most

1052
01:01:47,395 --> 01:01:54,415
John Gastil: exciting processes are those where even when you're on the losing side, you feel good, you feel good about it, you feel

1053
01:01:54,415 --> 01:01:59,520
like that was a fair process. I've facilitated processes before where my preferred choice got destroyed,

1054
01:01:59,840 --> 01:02:00,960
John Gastil: I still felt good.

1055
01:02:01,920 --> 01:02:06,000
John Gastil: How can that experience happen not just for a professional facilitator

1056
01:02:05,825 --> 01:02:07,505
John Gastil: whose job is neutrality,

1057
01:02:07,985 --> 01:02:09,185
John Gastil: but for a participant

1058
01:02:09,585 --> 01:02:16,240
John Gastil: and then the even harder one is for someone who was not in a deliberative process but was observing it or a

1059
01:02:16,240 --> 01:02:19,265
party to it, so if we have a mini public,

1060
01:02:20,840 --> 01:02:26,885
John Gastil: can the people in that country feel good about that process even if it results in an outcome that they wouldn't have

1061
01:02:26,885 --> 01:02:27,685
preferred?

1062
01:02:27,320 --> 01:02:30,600
John Gastil: That's fascinating to me and democracy really needs that.

1063
01:02:30,840 --> 01:02:35,705
John Gastil: It doesn't mean that you changed your mind, means that you didn't change your mind about the best outcome,

1064
01:02:35,945 --> 01:02:40,265
John Gastil: but you liked the process and you respected it. It's sort of like at the end of a sporting match,

1065
01:02:40,505 --> 01:02:46,302
John Gastil: I love seeing this, American football is brutal, it's a brutal sport, why I like it is complicated, I'm sure it has

1066
01:02:46,302 --> 01:02:49,200
something to do with my inner rebellion against Quakerism or something,

1067
01:02:49,840 --> 01:02:56,246
John Gastil: but I love at the end of the game when the players are hugging each other, exchanging jerseys just like in, you

1068
01:02:56,246 --> 01:02:57,120
know, football elsewhere,

1069
01:02:57,360 --> 01:02:59,120
John Gastil: and just in general, you know,

1070
01:03:00,065 --> 01:03:01,745
John Gastil: supporting each other, and

1071
01:03:02,225 --> 01:03:05,825
John Gastil: during the game when that happens, I love it even more, but it's more rare,

1072
01:03:08,625 --> 01:03:11,265
John Gastil: so I think that's a fun research puzzle.

1073
01:03:12,000 --> 01:03:15,840
John Gastil: What I said just a moment ago is kind of my general takeaway for people

1074
01:03:16,720 --> 01:03:19,680
John Gastil: at large, but for people who study democratic innovation,

1075
01:03:20,560 --> 01:03:26,160
John Gastil: the one small note I would offer, I think, is one of the lessons of British Columbia's Citizens Assembly,

1076
01:03:26,855 --> 01:03:27,655
John Gastil: which is

1077
01:03:27,975 --> 01:03:29,495
John Gastil: democratic innovations,

1078
01:03:30,695 --> 01:03:36,615
John Gastil: I think our impulse is to create a process that chooses the optimal solution,

1079
01:03:37,415 --> 01:03:39,895
John Gastil: that is, given all the information,

1080
01:03:39,895 --> 01:03:41,175
John Gastil: all the mathematics,

1081
01:03:41,175 --> 01:03:42,055
John Gastil: all the modeling,

1082
01:03:42,490 --> 01:03:47,850
John Gastil: this is the choice that is the most rational given the distribution of public values and so on,

1083
01:03:48,810 --> 01:03:50,250
John Gastil: that isn't necessarily

1084
01:03:50,250 --> 01:03:52,410
John Gastil: a politically viable solution.

1085
01:03:52,730 --> 01:03:55,690
John Gastil: What British Columbia chose was single transferable

1086
01:03:55,690 --> 01:04:00,255
John Gastil: vote, a system that almost no one there had ever heard of before the deliberation

1087
01:04:00,255 --> 01:04:03,455
John Gastil: and certainly people who learned about that recommendation

1088
01:04:03,455 --> 01:04:09,929
John Gastil: had to try to figure out what it meant. Many people still weren't sure what it meant, some voted for it, but

1089
01:04:09,929 --> 01:04:11,400
there was a nearby choice,

1090
01:04:11,720 --> 01:04:15,800
John Gastil: which would have been almost as optimal, but make a lot more sense to people,

1091
01:04:16,120 --> 01:04:19,000
John Gastil: right? You don't have to explain it with a five minute cartoon.

1092
01:04:20,040 --> 01:04:23,560
John Gastil: And so I think sometimes we have to think about deliberation

1093
01:04:23,765 --> 01:04:25,045
John Gastil: as fusing

1094
01:04:25,925 --> 01:04:27,925
John Gastil: sort of decision optimization

1095
01:04:28,165 --> 01:04:30,565
John Gastil: with kind of political viability

1096
01:04:30,565 --> 01:04:34,565
John Gastil: and, you know, kind of the sense making that people do when they're making choices,

1097
01:04:34,805 --> 01:04:35,605
John Gastil: and

1098
01:04:36,180 --> 01:04:40,420
John Gastil: be comfortable with an innovation that helps us make good choices

1099
01:04:40,980 --> 01:04:44,660
John Gastil: that people will broadly accept as opposed to recommending

1100
01:04:44,660 --> 01:04:47,220
John Gastil: perfect choices that nobody understands.

1101
01:04:48,100 --> 01:04:52,105
John Gastil: Thank you a lot, John, really. Oh, thank you so much, and thank you

1102
01:04:52,665 --> 01:04:55,225
John Gastil: anyone who took I'm the time to

1103
01:04:55,225 --> 01:05:01,423
John Gastil: sorry you didn't have better choices in your life that you found yourself here today, but hopefully we gave you a good

1104
01:05:01,423 --> 01:05:02,223
time.

1105
01:05:02,331 --> 01:05:04,091
Alessandro Oppo: I'm sure. I hope.

1106
01:05:06,491 --> 01:05:07,291
John Gastil: Well, they made it
